Home

 Articles

 Op-ed

 Authors

 FAQ

 Leaving Islam
 Library
 Gallery
 Comments
 Debates
 Forum

 

 

 

Muslims Comments 

Pages: 2  3  5  6  7  8  10 11  12  13  14  15


 

 2004/11/25

dear brother

i read you site and boy are you bright, the way you try to introduce the seed of doubt and leave people with uncertainty. those of weak faith you may sway but hey i`m `made of sticky clay there`s no way you will sway me. 

i know the truth by the truth i have faith with certainty i have a living faith 

let me offer you a challenge destroy my faith if you may and i will renounce islam you and sad old ibn warraq-beaten up by a mulla no doubt and then theres ulgy taslim nureema- has she  got a partner then theres irshad mani-modern day mutazilite finally that dutch somalian  

i feel a pithty for you losers in this life and the next. hey i will laugh at you on judgement day

salam

tanweer 

 Dear Tanweer,

All I can do is to shed light on facts so the seeing and see. I canít make the blind see. So if you are determined not to see, not me and not even God is able to make you see.

Thank you for feeling ďa pithtyĒ for me. You can save that noble sentiment for now. You may actually need it for yourself when you die and find out the truth. 


25/11/2004 10:34 PM

 Dear Mr Sina,  

The image one may have on you is that to be a person that would swear black and blue and debate the fact that the colour black is in fact the color white and vice versa, signifying that you are non receptive nor are you open minded, as this is evident throughout your writings.  

You play on words, twist issues quite well, not well enough!  

I have to affirm that you seem to understand psychology and the way one may respond to your sweeping statements presented with such ferocity.  

Furthermore, I am mortified of the disgusting foul language that some brothers employ! As the saying goes, ďTwo wrongs donít make a right!  

Regards,  

Eric Stavro  

 

Dear Eric

And would you care to be specific and show exactly which white I called black?    

For example when I say Muhammad raped women captured in war, is this not exactly what happened? Am I twisting anything?  

When I say he massacred his prisoners of war, tied their hands from behind and beheaded them throwing their bodies in a ditch is this twisting the facts?  

When I say he assassinated those who composed poetries criticizing him, including a mother of five while she was nursing her baby is this not the truth?

Be specific please. Which statement I made that in your opinion is twisting the facts? You know my challenge already. Prove me wrong and I will remove this site. If I am calling white something other than white, then it should be very easy for you to catch my lies and hey you win the prize. Do that and this site will be closed!  

Of course you canít. If you could you would have done it already. You are hurt for realizing how indefensible your belief is. It hurts because you find yourself cornered and your cherished belief canít stand the onslaught of criticism.  So my advice to you is to leave Islam. If you canít defend it, itís because it is false. You do not have to follow a false doctrine. You made a mistake converting to Islam. That is okay, we all made mistakes in our lives. As long as we are honest, mistakes can be mended. But once you lose the honesty, you are no more after the truth but try to dig your feet deeper in your error and try to defend your mistakes, then that is unforgivable.  

Read the articles in this site. If you think I made a mistake write in the forum and be specific. Just saying ďoh you twist the truthĒ does not cut it. Show my mistakes and let the world see where I lie. Then you can start beating your chest claiming victory. But I am sure if you are really honest, once you try to refute my arguments against Islam, youíll see that you canít and then hopefully youíll start seeing the light.  

Everyday people like you are leaving Islam. You seem to be embarrassed of the conduct of your brothers. What would you do if I show to you Muhammad was even a worse thug?

Regards 

Ali Sina 

 


From: "jani gudia" <[email protected]>  
Subject: to a fag..
Date: Thu, 25 Nov 2004 01:19:05 +0000

umm... ur a fag!! u know that?!?! u have no idea wat islam is all about.. and if u did, u wud never say that about islam!!!! u have no idea.. and if u turned in to an american.. then u made a BIG mistake.. cuz americans are th ones that prove themselves rong every single day.. and ur prolly one of them!!! i def disagree with ur opinion.. u make urself sound really dumb!!! the Quran is the best and peaceful thing that came on earth.. and u have no fucking right to call mohammad a rapist.. u know americans take first prize for raping.. and ur one of them.. ur obviously mistaken and dont know anything. cuz if u did, u woudl know that islam is awesome.. u know wat?!!? i dunno y i even try.. cuz ur gonna find out who was right and who was rong wen u burn in hell... jz u wait.. i hope allah gives u the worst punishment he has.. and if i were 2 find u anywhere.. i would beat the shit out of u!! u lil fag! trying 2 make ez money.. jz u wait.. and i hope that u realize that ur wrong and allah gives u enuff sence and u betta pray to allah that u dun go 2 hell after calling mohammad (may peace be upon him) a rapist, terrorsits, and all the motha fuckn names u thought of.. and u no wat?!?! uknow that americans are the ones that bombed the pentagona and all those other things!! go 2 hell fag! really! i mean it!!

i hope u pay.. i really hate ppl like u.. even americans are better than u fag!!! my friends understand and then theres u a wanna be white- no one is gonna accept u!!! fag!!!!! thats all i have 2 say 2 u...

KHUDAHAFIZ!!!!

how do u alike that?!?! do u know wat the means!!!?!?!?


From: "eric stavros" <[email protected]>  
Subject: RE: why i left islam
Date: Tue, 23 Nov 2004 09:36:20 +0200

 

I seriously doubt that you were once a 'Muslim'. You might have been a muslim by name but not by nature, and i guess you are trying to strengthen your argument by claiming that you were once a Muslim but, you have left the religeon due to its inconsistencies and flaws.  

I really wonder how much have you been paid to create such a website, i guess you are soiling or trying to soil Islam. Well guess what Islam is the fastest growing religeon in the world. Scare you ? It should. What des this denote to you ?  

Seriously I would say you are nothing more than a cheap skank!  

Regards,

 

 

You are absolutely right. I have never been a real Muslim except by name. Once I read the Quran and realized what the real Islam means I stopped calling myself Muslim.  

It is my conviction that the majority of Muslims are not real Muslims either. They are Muslims by name only. The real Muslims are the terrorists, the Jihadis and those who kill hundreds of children, behead people who have spent their entire life serving the sick and shout Allah is great.    

No matter how much I am paid to create this site, I have issued a challenge that should anyone prove my charges against Muhammad to be wrong I will remove this site. Isnít this good enough? Imagine, I am promising to forego the millions and millions of dollars that I am being paid to create this site if anyone can prove me wrong. Can you do that?  

No dear, Islam is the fastest dying religion. You better update your information. Yes Muslims are polyprofilogenitive, like rabbit. But that is the feature of all undedicated people. However, they also die much faster because they fight constantly and live in squalid conditions. But the major blow to Islam is the fact that the majority that is Muslim only by name are leaving Islam. And yes it would be really scary if Muslims become the majority. That would be the end of civilization. But that wonít happen. Weíre here to expose the lies of Islam and since we have started this campaign Islam has been in retreat. We are millions and are growing.


Date: Fri, 19 Nov 2004 21:10:47 -0800 (PST)
From: Send an Instant Message "nasir choudhery" <[email protected]>  
Subject: you will be burned if you do not repent

 

i have read some of your evil work and i just want to let you know that there always been people like you (enemies of Islam) and it sounds like that you have read quran and you know there is a sewer punishment for evil people like yourself at the day of judgment if they don't repent nor stop their nonsense. so please give yourself a favor and ask forgiveness before the day of judgment. i guarantee you that no matter what you try a true Muslim will never ever become a non-believer. again give yourself a favor by asking God forgiveness and save yourself from a horrible day of judgment. 

 

This site is not for true Muslims. The true Muslims are in the camps of Osama Bin Laden. This site is for good people who think Islam is a religion of God and peace. And yes they are leaving Islam once they see Islam is a satanic cult of terror and hate. So don't worry, you and other good Muslim are immune to any rational influence. 


 

2004/11/16

hi

i just want to thank you for your informative website. All the hate you have towards islam made me a stronger believer...These days i was having doubts about my religion but now i am sure that i am in the right religion and there is nothing better than this thank you

ayesha

 

It is my pleasure to be of help. Please let all Muslims who are in doubt know of this site so all of them regain their faith.  

BTW, which part of Islam did you love most? The part that Muhammad raped the women captured in wars or the fact that he massacred their husbands and looted their properties? Or maybe your faith grew because you came to understand that your prophet was a gangster who used to eliminate his opponents by assassinating them. Or perhaps you realized Muhammad must have had some divine knowledge when he said women are deficient in intelligence and when you look at yourself you wonder how he could have known that.  

I am happy that I helped you find your way. But please share with us which ones of the crimes of Muhammad have helped you become stronger in your faith.  


From: [email protected]  
Date: Tue, 9 Nov 2004 01:59:04 EST
Subject: hey there yahudi
 

may you burn in hell INSHALLAH


From:

"Rehan Gardezi" <[email protected]

Date:

Thu, 04 Nov 2004 21:35:11 -0600

Dear Sir/Mame,

The pictures you put on your website are some of them of Ashura, and i read your comments about it. You wrote bad comments about it. You better delete them, if i findout who you are, i'll fuck you, peace of shiet! You better not say anything about my Imam Ali , and never say a bad thing about day of Ashura. Tear you apart! FUCK YOU ONCE AGAIN,.

 


 

were you a muslim really?  

how can u convince me that u were a muslim before. Anyone can accuse u of being non-muslim and propagating anti-islam theories. Being a non-muslim, i never believed that anyone can hate qoran and islam so much. Thanks for ur patience. 

 

Well I have to be honest and say that I have never been a Muslim in my life, only I thought I was. After I read the Quran and found out the truth about Islam, it became clear to me that I was never a Muslim to begin with. If ever I called myself a Muslim, it's because of my ignorance of Islam.

And believe me, once you realize the lies that Muhammad said, and how he took you for a ride, you'll start hating that man and his cult so intensely that you can't remain silent. It's not just me, if you read the articles in this site and visit our forum, you'll meet a lot of ex-Muslims who hate Islam, the Quran and its psychopath lying author.   


From: "Aziz" <[email protected]
Date: Wed, 27 Oct 2004 11:23:46 +0200
You really are in need of a shrink,you facist pig.

 


From: "Timur Horvath" <[email protected]
Subject: You didn't understand anything!!
Date: Tue, 26 Oct 2004 02:37:03 

 I am here to warn you,

You didnít understand ISLAM (Islam is PEACE)! Or you understood Islam, but you want to damage the image of this religionÖ..! If it is so you will be punished!! But, if you really didnít understand the idea, the message of Islam then it is better to say nothing before you are starting talking shit!!!  

I warn you! And I pray for those guys who wantís to create a false picture of Islam that they will be punished hard!!!    

Seyed Timur-Reza


From: [email protected]  
Date: Mon, 18 Oct 2004 08:48:09 EDT

Hey idiot. I've seen what happens to people who are like you. Man they are sooooo ugly. Reallly, im serious, their inner uggliness is shown in their appearance. This is a just retribution from Allah. When you are lying in your grave, and youve got snakes and stuff biting you, your coffin closing in on you crushing you, fire burning your backside, youll see the whole reality before you, and then you'll realise how wrong you are. Youll wish you could just have one more chance to go back and change yourself, but it will be too late for you. You still have a chance now to change and repent, and make ammends. But you seem so deep seated in your hatred and bias and ignorance. After reading your articles, i now believe more strongly in my faith of Islam. You misquote and lie so much. It is astonishing. The muslims who you debated with, you used clever tacticts to sway the argument. Like you moved away from the topic at hand, and started talking about other stuff. Your website is useless. Even in my own home town, the mosques are packed, i see young people with beards walking down the street. I see ladies wearing hijaab and covering up. The greeting of sallaam is extended openly, and i myself offer it to muslims when i meet them. I love my Allah, I love my prophet Muhammed (peace be upon him), and i love the Qur'an. I love Islam.

I will bring up  my children to be good muslims, so they can learn good manners, and learn

about humanity, and how to treat people well. They will learn to respect women as important members of societyand not just as sex objects, as you kaafirs like to show them for your own amusement. They will learn to respect their parents and elders, and be kind to neighbours, and to relatives.They will learn about charity, insha-Allah. You, are deluded, and living in deception now. You have been decieved by the kaafir west, and by your own materialistic selfishness. Your articles show that you obviously had not much knowledge in the first place, and also that you had weak iman. Shaitaan just toolk advantage of this, and made you into a complete kaafir. I look forward to the day your site is closed down.


From: [email protected]  
Date: Mon, 18 Oct 2004 08:21:47 EDT

You stupid bastard.

you will have to die one day, and when you do, your ass will burn in hell. Then you will realise the wrong of what you did. You run after these non-muslims and kiss their back sides. Intelligent muslims wont believe any of this crap. Your call to all muslims to leave their faith! What a joke. We're not all materialistic, kaafir loving, selfish, morons like you. You said you will shut down your nonsensse site if proved wrong: I'll prove you wrong right now. Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world. Now tell me, if it contains all those errors and contradictions which you claim, then why do people look into it, study it, learn it, and then embrace it. I'm sure youve heard of all the famous non-muslims who embraced islam, read what they say without prejudice.They see the truth. They dont just shut their eyes to it because of their bias and prejudice. They embrace it of their own free will, because they see the beauty and purity of it, and realise that this is a message from on-high. At the end of the day, you are in Allah's sight, as we all are, wether you like it or not, and he will deal with you in the most fitting manner. You'll see, if not in this life, then definately in the next life.

And id advise you to get a life, you sad piece of crap

 

 

This is not a proof. What we have here is a combination of three logical fallacies. One is the claim that Islam is the fastest growing religion and because of that it is true. To see my response to this claim see here.

The other is a threat of hell and punishment. This is no logic at all but fear mongering. See my response here

The third is ad hominem or insult and that is also no proof that Islam is a true religion. 

If you read the entire pages of Muslims' comments, you'll see that these three fallacies are repeated in all the emails they sent to me. None of that will prove that Muhammad was a prophet of God.  


2004/10/11

"get lost" <[email protected]>

what! just becuase you are an idiot doing all this it doesnt mean everyone else is going to follow you. you will be punished by god trust me. better start regretting it cause when you die you will know you bastard


2004/10/10

"Duane Hill" <[email protected]>

I started reading your site with high hopes of finding FACTS and HISTORICALLY VERIFIABLE EVENTS to use in debate. All I found was an incredible amount of verbosity. Totally useless. You talk to much. Get to the point, say what you have to say, then shut up.

I can also give it to you in one sentence: 

Muhammad was a psychopath, and his cult is evil, so leave it.  

This is the gist of all what I wrote. 


 

"mohamed" <[email protected]>

2004/10/08

 I SINCERELY HOPE THAT ALLAH MAY GUIDE YOU ,AND SAVE YOU AND ALLYOUR FELLOW SCUM FROM THE CERTAIN HELLFIRE THAT YOU ARE FACING.


Date: Sun, 19 Sep 2004 22:16:41 -0700 (PDT)
From:  "Nurun chowdhury" <[email protected]>  
Subject: Truth will come to you soon

Our Creator said,Every soul will test death. When death will reach us we will know the truth . Soon Ali sina, you and your friend Pat Robertson will know the truth also, you will regret that day,  but NO BODY WILL RETURN TO LIFE to correct their mistake . You and people like you will be sorry that day ,


Dear Mr. Ali Sina,  

Thank you for your service.  I would just like to tell you that I am offended from your challenge and from the out-of-context use of the

Q'ran. 

May peace guide you to prosperity.

 Heya Speakloud

 

Dear Heya

Why are you offended? Challenge means prove me wrong and Iíll remove this website? What is so offensive about this?  

I tell you what is offensive. Offensive is when someone says: ďbelieve in the absurdities that I tell you or Iíll kill youĒ. Now that is offensive.  

My challenge is not offensive but to those who feel unable to meet that challenge. If I quote the Quran out of context then you can easily prove me wrong and make me shut the site down.  

I am already guided and in peace. But prosperity would be nice. Thank you for wishing it for me.  


 

From: [email protected]  
Date: Mon, 13 Sep 2004 16:04:25 EDT
Subject: ONE GOOD IS KNOWELDGE ONE EVIL IS IGRNORANCE, U ARE AN IGNORANT LOST SOUL
ALI SINA    
How dare u call yourself a man of knoweldge about GOD, your no one but another human sinner full of egos and racist mind, u who call yourself know it all, u should be in prison for ur causing nothing but racist comments and promoting hate against muslims everywhere, your preacher of terrorisme, and u think ur doing good to the world, if u choose islam as your enemy, will u coward islam is your worst nightmare, U RACIST CIVILISATION, SINNERS, U WHO PREACH THE WORLD RACIST DESCRIMINATIVE COMMENTS AGAINST ARABS AND MUSLIMS IF UR DEMOCRACY IS FOR TRUE, U SHOULD BE BEHIND BARS CHARGED UNDER TERRORISME ACT, U THINK U BELONG TO HUMAN RACE OR UR FIGHTING FOR JUSTICE, IF ISLAM AS U PRETEND IN YOUR PROPOGANDA IS AN EVIL RELIGION, FOR GOD SAKE, UR GOD MUST BE SATAN, UR DOOMED IN LIVE AND IN HELL U SHALL BE, U HATRED OF EVERYTHING LIVING U WHO U THINK IF JESUS WERE ALIVE WILL PRAISE U FOR BEING A RACIST AND KILLERS OF INNOCENT CHILDREN, UR LEADERS ARE THE BARABIRC RACIST DEMOCRACY, U SICK MINDED DEVILS, U TALK ABOUT GOD, WHILE U SELL YOUR CHILDREN TO PEDOPHILES, UR WOMEN ARE THE MOST CHEAPEST CREATURES IN EARTH, AND U THINK U BELONG TO HUMAN RACE, U WHO OWN THIS SITE, U SHALL BE PROSECUTED FOR PREACHING AND PROMOTING HATE, TOWARDS ANOTHER RACE, UR DEMOCRACY STUFF IT IN YOUR U KNOW WHERE, CAUSE UR ALL CRIMINALS RACIST HATRED TO HUMANITY AND PEACE, SO SHUT UR MOUTH AND GO PRAY TO YOUR GOD TO SAVE YOU FROM UR EVIL MIND,. SICK BASTARD

 


 

From: "Juffrey Mohamed J Mohamed" <[email protected]>  
Subject: Re: PEACE
Date: Mon, 13 Sep 2004 16:58:16 +0000

 I've read your articles. You do not know the actual meaning of all the surah mentioned. You got it all wrong. I don't know where you learn or study Islam.  

Have you read or hear the latest news on Iraq ? Americans killing the innocents. Guest what they said of the killings, 'We have meet our objective'. I supposed those Americans are Christians.  

What about the Jews? They killed the innocent and the defenceless. I think you still have alot to learn.....whats is going on in this world  


 

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Op-ed Authors Debates Leaving Islam FAQ
Comments Library Gallery Video Clips Books Sina's Challenge
 

  ©  copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.