|
| |
Muslim's comments 5
Pages 1
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 11
12
 |
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
"emotional
robot" <[email protected]>
30 May 2002
| Subject: |
Re: Challenge - wont disappoint you |
I
probably wont be able to answer you (not that I cannot hold my own) -
oo young (good excuse - pity it wont last forever).
ever Heard of Dr. Muhammad Tahir Ul Qadri.
Currently
he is the greatest Islamic scholar. Extermely popular - as he has the
world largest Islamic Organisation in the world. That is true. Its in
more then 70 countries. And as you put it a "Fundamentalist"
of course we muslims perefer "Advocates of Political
Islam." (charming)
He has also the largest educational agenda under
he heading of NGO. He has recieved many international awards
(biographical) and for achievement.
Under the american biographical institue.... he is
recognized as one of the greatest 500 intellectuals.
If are serious about a CHALLENGE then why dont you
go and meet him. You will not be the first... many have done so before
you. Sorry I am too "Junior" to get you the relevant contacts
.... but if you contact him directly .... you will be heard.
Here are the contact details.....
www.minhaj.org
and
www.minhaj.net
Of course if you are not a small fish in the pond
like me .... and simply hate islam (which you do) without any
"intellectualism" and "compassionate". Not like
hose listing of dfferent anti -islamic sites you list ... not like
hat.... pah! do you accept christianty or hinduism or judaism, or
Secualarity. You can only accept one point of view. Then in "Islam
bashing" you cannot er allaince up with others .... considering you
know most of them are flase accusations and oppose your point of view.
Just because its against islam, it does not make it true!
Compassionate?
Well over a billion adherents of Islam, are human
oo... and dont kid your
self (the majority do not hate other on grounds of religion).
Plus in your er "Islam Bashing"
(been done from the start) when you do join with other
"anti-muslim" what about Justice.
Let me ask you ... are you Just? What about
injustices committed against innocent muslims .... (of course, i do not
mean religious )
... take case of Palestine ..... over a thousand
killings of muslims in Gujarat .... over 2,000 killed in Lebanon by
christian Phlanges? ... 8,000 men killed by Slobodan Milosviec
If you advocate such brutality and er complete wipe
out of muslims (many do on the WWW and you know that too).
Although you have never made your position clear?
Have you?
Hope you luck? And yes I will personally love you
seeing head-off with man i REGARD TO BE THE BEST IN THE WORLD.
MOHAMMED AMIN
=====
M.Amin www.instella.net
Ali Sina Responds
Dear Mohammed,.
Please contact these people
and tell them to disprove me. I bet they won’t and they will tell you
not to read my site. You want to bet?
And to answer your questions,
no I am not in cahoots with any other religion. I believe humanity will
be much better without them. Yet I do not oppose beliefs that do not
advocate violence even though those beliefs are false.
As for killings, I am against
all killings irrespective of the beliefs of the victims. However the
Muslim victims are not victims of religious hate. No body kills Muslims
just because they are Muslims. Innocent Muslims are often killed in
retaliatory attacks by those who have been victimized by Muslim
errorists. In every case I can think of the war has been instigated by
Muslims. They are to be blamed to start the hostilities. The reason is
quiet obvious. You just have to look into Quran to see why Muslims hate
everyone in the world.
Regards,
Ali Sina |
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
"Sarosh Hashmi" <[email protected]>
29 May 2002
U Basturd go to hell
How dare u write about our Holy Prophet (PBUH)
Go to hell
Go to hell
Go to hell
Go to hell
Go to hell
Go to hellllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
>--- Dr Khalid Sager <[email protected]>
wrote:
Mate, I dont know who you are but you are certainly
spreading lies about Islam. May Allah (SWT) Guide you. That is only one
prayer I can pray for you.
Prof.Dr.Khalid Rashid Sager
Sydney, Australia
Ali Sina Responds
Dear Professor Doctor.
If what I write is lies you
certainly can demonstrate them. I have issued a challenge: Should any
person prove me wrong I will remove my site” The fact that neither you
nor any other person has been able to do so is clear indication that Islam
is a false religion and Muhammad was a sick man. No wonder ALL Islamic
countries are so poor and miserable. As if we needed more proof. But my
whole site is full of proof if you cared to read.
If you want to respond please
respond in our forum.
http://host22.hrwebservices.net/~faithfr/FFI/phpBB2/index.php
27 May 2002
Dear Mr. Ali Sina
You are certainly one of those perople whose eyes
have been shut and I dont want to waste my time with you. I can only pray
o Allah Almighty to open your eyes. Dont bother to reply me again as I
would delete your email without reading it .
Prof.Dr.Khalid Rashid Sager
This Professor Doctor send me an email and I
responded. I did not approach him first. See his reaction! This
is the state of the mind of a Muslim "Professor Doctor".
What can we expect from the illiterate Muslim masses? Unfortunately
he majority of Muslims, just like their prophet, are illiterate. May
God (if he exists) help the students of such professor doctors Now you
know why ALL Islamic countries are is such miserable state.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
[email protected]
24 May 2002
ali sina
you are mistaken, and in grave danger..... bad
combination
point is ... you humiliated over a billion. you used
false interpretations of the Ayat of the Quran
that's why you have in mind that we think the earth
is flat. Well guess what , we don't, the quran doesn't say that the earth
is flat.
Before you go on givin false statements about Allah's
religion and prophets , read Ahmed Deedat's books. May be they'll put some
sense in your head.
and if there were errors in the Quran, don't you
hink that Arabic teachers would have identified that......?
We are not racists...i got best friends which are
non-muslims, and islam urges one to free slaves on many occasions and as
you can see most of the Muslim thinkers have said that people had no right
o enslave other human beings.
The prophet had many wives to spread Islam and that's
another story.
Allah was there before the universe for He created
everyone and everything.
One piece of advise , although you and your likes
don't deserve it.... read the Quran again, with it's proper TRANSLATION
and INTERPRETATION, Ahmed Deedat's books and debates on video would help
alot and see what White, American , Women and men that converted to Islam
have to say about what you say
.
Ali Sina responds:
The most obvious proof that I am wrong is of
course the fact that I am in danger. This irrefutable proof of Islam
has helped it remain unchallenged so far.
Also it is always the fault of the
ranslations and interpretations. I wonder which translation is the
right one? However in my case I do not rely on translations. I read Quran
in Arabic and I find it even more
damaging.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
"Christopher Wellers" <[email protected]>
11 May 2002
Hello Ali
You know, you got a quiet interesting website over
here that has attracted many attentions, And guess what? It got mine,
should people give you credit for that?
You say that you have exposed the truth behind Islam,
And you mentioned how aggressive Islam is, And you pretended like you care
about others religions, which is obviously bunch of porpaganda, If the
point of that website is to tell muslims how bad their religion is, then I
am afraid that's not going to happen, Because the way you attacked their
religions, and of course any non-muslims who will visit your website will
see how ignorant you are, We all know that each Quranic verse that was
used in your website had it's own incident, And it's not like The bible or
he Talmud do not have such verses.
Anyways, Any muslim would know that your excuses are
all false by reading the quranic Tafseer...
Funny thing is; you say you care about people, yet
you hurt them by attacking their religion, and it's very unfortunate to
see a person with all of this knowledge carrying some real bad intensions
owards something beautiful such as Islam.
I used to be a muslim hater myself, And decided to do
he same thing as you, I read the quran, And found a lot of verses which
recalled for killing infidels and so on, But at the end I discovered that
it was helping me in any way so I decided to drop it, and read the quran
once again with good intensions, And guess what? I was totally convinced,
All of these recent theories mentioned in the quran that was revealed a
housand years ago didn't only convince me but made me convert to islam,
And I even thought about it, You say Muhammed was a false prophet but how
was he able to create such a nation in 20 years only? Can a man do the
same thing right now?
Reading the quran has made me learn one thing, That
he radicals we see on TV do not represent islam at all, Each religion has
it's own radicals and they are all worse than each other, And if we ever
want to know what islam is really is, Look at it back then when the
prophet was alive, They had such great prosperity back then, Nowadays
muslims lack the knowledge of their own religion so you can't blame Islam
for that.
Also something else which attracted my attention was
saying that Allah means a moon god? Have you ever encountered an
arab-christian and asked him what they call god? I am sure he's going to
say Allah, therefore it's the arabic name of god, either way; The god
muslims worship is the creator of the universe, the creator of me, you and
all of the mankind.
And finally, I'd like to say, do you enjoy shoving
words up people's mouthes? Is hurting and attacking others is your
defination of Respect and rational thinking? Why don't you show people
what better religion they can actually follow then? And don't forget to
compare it to islam with open minded intensions because I am sure you'll
notice how wrong you are at the end.
-Peace,
CJ
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
"bali kilva" <[email protected]>
10 May 2002
Hi,
Good point. It
doesn't sink only if they don't try to understand why something is being
said. Unfortunate for you
hat you are a great writer and researcher but with a less open mind.
Don't take it offensively, I was the same way, perhaps still am.
You spend too much time researching Quran and Hadith.
What you should do is
try to understand them and do it alone.
You will know.
Great article though with misinterpretetions, hope
you catch on to the truth.
Regards,
Bali Kilva
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
