Ali Sina vs. Mustafa Basheer
what you are saying is that you would follow your brain and not your
heart. Mr Sina,
Oh sure. Of course I am
not going to follow my heart. Heart is very misleading. What do you think of
those who follow cults? Do they follow their brain? Of course not! They follow
their hearts but heart can be fooled and as the result they are fooled.
First you have to
establish the path that you are taking is the right one and this can be done
only by using your brain.
Even if I choose to follow my
heart, why would I want to follow Islam? This is a very ugly faith. It only
attracts the criminals. Decent humans are disgusted by it. Are you sure you
follow your heart? or is it fear? Are you not appalled by the violence and hate
in the Quran? What part of the Quran you think is appealing? Islam is a fear
based religion. The ultimate argument that Muslims present is fear of
hope you do realise our limitations as human beings.
Yes there is a limitation in human brain but that is all we have. With an
airplane you canít travel to the moon. There is a limitation to the airplane.
Beyond certain altitudes it just canít go. Would you leave the pain in mid air
to go to the moon without it? That would be quite foolish. No, you would try to
build a different space ship to propel you to the moon. But still you would
follow the same scientific principles and follow the same laws of nature. So yes
there is a limitation to logics but it would be foolish to abandon it and
embrace irrationality find the truth.
Even if we find other means to access the truth, like intuition or similar
faculties they cannot be illogical.
|Now how do you know your
"intellect" is correct? How can you be certain your
intelligence has not betrayed you.
Tell me how do you know
that your heart has not betrayed you? It has betrayed many people. The followers
of David Koresh were betrayed by their hearts, the followers of Jim Jones,
Heavenís Gate or all other cults were/are betrayed by their hearts. How do you
know you are not betrayed by your heart?
What do you say about
the suicide bombers? Donít you think they are victims of their faith? Donít
you think their hearts is betraying them? If they used their brain, they would
not have done this stupid thing. Killing innocent people to go to heaven? Is
there anything more insane than that? They are following their hearts and not
their brains. No matter how flawed our intellect may be, it is the only tool we
have and it is far better equipped to see the truth than our feelings. The
good news is that intellect and human knowledge are expanding and every day we can learn something new. Look at the product of the intellect. Technology and
science are the products of intellect. They are not perfect but every day we
invent new things. Would you go and live in a cave just because technology and
science are not perfect?
Intellect can fail also
but there is a better chance to correct it. Intellect is corrigible. The more
you learn the more you can rely on your intellect. It is not perfect but it is
expanding and is far more reliable than feelings. Our senses say the Earth is
flat. Our intellect says it is round. Which one is correct?
|There are still so many
mysterious phenomenon in this world for which science has no answers.
Yes of course, but this
does not warrant accepting any nonsense just because science has no answers. I
donít know what is in Neptune; does this allow me to believe
is populated by two headed creatures that fly by wiggling their nose? If we
donít know something, it means we donít know! This is no excuse to invent
fairytales and believe in absurdities.
|My point is, what may
seemingly look wrong or inappropriate may have a hidden meaning
Yes it may, but who said
you should believe in absurdities just because it may have hidden meanings?
Until you find that hidden meaning you are better off not to believe in
anything. What if that hidden meaning is not the same that you believe. Your
faith in absurdity will hinder you from seeing the truth. One must not believe
in anything without evidence.
Allah alone knows.
Wait a minute. How do
you know Allah alone knows? How do you know that Allah exists and if he exists
what proof you have that he is God? These are mere suppositions you are making.
It is okay to assume things, but it is not okay to believe in your own
assumptions. This is like believing in a figment of your own imagination.
To me, it would make
more sense in polygamy to allow 2 women at a time rather than 4. What
ever pros muslim websites have given works best for 2 women rathen than
four. But, I am content with the knowledge that Allah has seen a reason
First of all why two?
Polygamy encourages rivalry and makes the cowives jealous of each other. These
are not healthy feelings. They grow with low self esteem and raise their
children with low self esteem. Low self esteem is the root cause of most human
problems. Dysfunctional families give rise to dysfunctional societies.
But that is another subject. Let us
concentrate now on what you said. ďI am content with the knowledge
that Allah has seen a reason for thisĒ.
Fair enough! What about the
terrorists who murder innocent people? They canít explain their actions but
they commit this heinous crime because they think this is what God wants from
them and it is not up to them to question the wisdom of God. Like you their
faith is not based on logic but on their heart. So you can't prove them that
they are wrong, because like you they have put aside the logics. How can we
reason with the terrorists when you say reason is not good.
One of Shoko Asaharaís followers was Dr. Ikuo Hayashi, a
renowned doctor. Following the orders of Asahara, he planted the toxic sarin gas
in the subways of
causing the death of a dozen of people and life injuries to hundreds. Later he
confessed that while sitting in the train, he looked at the woman sitting in
front of him and said to himself that if he releases this toxic gas, for sure
she will die. For a moment he thought he should not do it, but he fought back
the thought and convinced himself that God knows best and he should not question
the wisdom of Asahara. How could a brilliant scientist of world fame become so
fooled? He wept in his trial and strived to find an answer to that question
himself. Yet at the moment, he thought he must do whatever his guru says, that
it is not up to him to doubt and question the wisdom of God and his
representative on Earth. Isn't this exactly how Muslims think? Dr. Hayashi is
not an evil man. He had done discoveries in medicine. He and his wife, also a
doctor, were genuinely good persons. They tried to find better ways to heal
people and this was the reason they went after holistic medicine and meditation,
which eventually led them to Asahara. These smart people fell prey to a con
artist, surrendered their will and intelligence to him, lost their sense
of right and wrong and committed murder. All Dr. Hayashi wanted to do was to
help people. He ended killing people.
Ikuo Hayashi, a famous doctor who had done so much for
medicine, became a terrorist because like you and like all other believers,
including the terrorists, he did not dare to question the wisdom of God. What
God? He believed Asahara is a messenger of God. Did he have any proof for that?
No, he just followed his heart. You my friend are doing the same. What proof is
there that Muhammad was a prophet of God? First give me that proof. Once you
accept someone blindly you fight back your own commonsense and say ďI am
content with the knowledge that Allah has seen a reason for thisĒ. Have you
established first that this is from God? How? You have fallen into the same trap
that Dr. Hayashi fell. You believe without any evidence. If Hayashi was wrong,
who guarantees that that you are right? He was a smart man and famous for his
work. Are you as smart as him?
| p3 | p4
| p5 | p6