Leaving Islam




“According to the forth school of law (Maliki), any prayer that a woman leads others in – whether women, men, or mixed – is invalid”, concluded this person. Ali ibn Abi Talib is reported to have said, "The woman is not to lead (Salat)."  

There have been a few Muslim scholars who thought there is no harm in women leading the prayers. Among them was Imam Abu Ja'far Ibn Jarir Al-Tabari (died 310AH). Al-Tabari was an absolute mujtahid and is known as the Imam of the Exegetes (Mufassirin). But his school didn't thrive and it didn't last as the 4 surviving schools did. Those who maintained such views, were rare and could not support their views with the Quran and Hadith. Therefore those views were debunked by the Muslim fundamentalists and were forgotten.  

The arguments presented by the fundamentalists against women leading in prayer can be summed up as follow:  

-         If it was permissible, it would have been reported from the Salaf us Saliheen.

-    Since the Sunnah for women in prayer is for them to be behind the men, it is known from that that it is not permitted for them to be in front of them.

An scholar known as Abdullah bin Mas'ud said: "Put them back to where Allah put them back." Al-San'ani and Tabarani reported it. It is also mentioned in Majma' Al-Zawa'id.  

The most conclusive evidence that women cannot lead men in prayer is a Hadith reported from Muhammad who said: "The best ranks of the men are those at the front. And the worst of them are those at the back. And the best ranks of the women are those at the back. And the worst of them are those at the front."

This Muslim concluded that such an act contravenes and puts under question the wisdom of Allah and is tantamount to follow in the footsteps of Satan. He wrote: “So it becomes clear that such people who insist on the permissibility of a woman leading men in prayer have nothing firm to rely on in their position other than the following of their fancies and what their lusts dictate to them.”  

Another Islamic scholar, Dr. Sheikh Yusuf Al-Qaradawi writes: “Throughout Muslim history it has never been heard of a woman leading the Friday Prayer or delivering the Friday sermon."  He argued that “prayer in Islam is an act that involves different movements of the body… Hence, it does not befit a woman, whose structure of physique naturally arouses instincts in men, to lead men in Prayer and stand in front of them, for this may divert the men’s attention from concentrating in the Prayer and the spiritual atmosphere required… Hence, it is to avoid the stirring the instincts of men that the Sharia dictates that only men can call for Prayer and lead people in the Prayer, and that women’s rows in Prayer be behind the men.”  

Supporting Dr. Qaradawi’s position, Imam Shaker El-Sayed, former general secretary of the Muslim American Society tells the Muslim women: “There is an established historic consensus among all Muslim scholars that a woman may lead other women in prayer, but she should not lead men in prayer". "This is not because she is a woman,” he said, “but because of the awkwardness of the position we Muslims take when we prostrate in prayer. These positions would make both women and men uncomfortable when a woman bows down and prostrates in front of men.”  

"Awkward" is an understatement. One question that is not considered is why worshipping God should require such awkward positions? There is nothing spiritual and holy in these silly positions. They are in fact ridiculous. They are embarrassing and not befitting for intelligent people. Nothing in Islam is catered to intelligent people. 


Don't Muslims know that the rituals of Salat, including fasting and hajj that constitute the pillars of Islam are borrowed from the pre Islamic pagans of Mecca whom Muhammad berated and called ignorant? If they were idolaters and ignorant, why use their rituals? Couldn’t God invent new rituals that did not resemble the rituals of the pagans? It is obvious that Allah’s knowledge and creativity of religion was limited to Muhammad’s experience.

Another Muslim writer whose articles are published in various Islamic sites and who is an avid supporter of Islamic terrorism, in an article that he titled “Idiocy of Gender Equality: The Case of the Woman Imam” argued:  

“Therefore, those who have their faith in gender equality that is rooted in feminism which forms part of the current secular values would naturally conclude that religions are man-made: synthetic. But this conclusion also in turn raises another question, why men have been so successful in dominating women, shaping history, society and civilisations? So, one may argue that known human history actually demonstrates the non-existence of gender equality. It is a recent invention by some idealists; in contrast, religions have always existed throughout human history as if it is an essential part of human nature.” 


Back    <   1   2    3   >    Next 








Articles Op-ed Authors Debates Leaving Islam FAQ
Comments Library Gallery Video Clips Books Sina's Challenge

  ©  copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.