Home

 Articles

 Op-ed

 Authors

 FAQ

 Leaving Islam
 Library
 Gallery
 Comments
 Debates
  Links
 Forum

 

 

 Edip Yuksel vs. Ali Sina

Round VI -17

Back  <      >   Next 

In the forum of this site, one of the Submitters, follower of the same doctrine advocated by our friend Edip Yuksel, posted the information that I provided when I purchased the domain of this site for everyone to see. [1] [2] [3] Of course I had the presence of mind not to make public my real address and telephone number when I registered the domain. The information is not correct or I would have not seen this day.

The person that posted that information, thought that the information is correct and since he himself did not have the means to deal with me according to the Islamic principles, he hoped one of his Jihadi brothers would see that and would take care of me. Who else could possibly be interested to learn about my whereabouts?

Ironically this individual claims that as a Submitter his version of Islam is the reformed one and that the followers of this sect are humanized, that unlike their Sunni and Shiite coreligionists they do not kill the apostates and reject all the barbarities of Islam denouncing them as the products of the hadith and that as the “Quran-only” Muslims, they are different. 

To a person who does not knows Islam and is not aware that the brutality of this religion stems from the Quran itself, this group seems to present a shimmer of hope. These Muslims, familiar with the Western mindset, know exactly what their audience wants to hear and they tune their instruments accordingly.  

However, although dissimulation is an Islamic art, not all of them are good at it. Often they do and say things that reveal their true nature. For example this Submitter with the illusion of endangering my life thought that by revealing that fake information about me to the public he is going to give a hand to his terrorist brothers to assassinate me. When asked to explain his motives he wrote:

Apostasy is not what gets one killed. It's a combination of being controversial and having a high profile.

Now if what you presented was not couched in so much hatred - and what you have written above is evidence of your single minded hatred of all Islam - because you make it patently clear regarding your disrespect for the common holy text of all Muslims - then you might be able to do what you do and not be so controversial.

However your post above is enough to convince me that you are absolute in your hatred and that your posts about love and mending are hollow.

Most people give you the benefit of the doubt and wish you guidance but I have an altogether different prayer in relation to you Ali -

O Lord, you have given Ali Sina and his followers freedom of speech and action in this world. O Lord, they only use them to repulse others from Your path. O Lord, wipe out their actions, and harden their hearts to prevent them from believing, until they see the painful retribution.”

 

So it is clear that Submitters, just like all other Muslims think it is perfectly justifiable to kill someone if he is “controversial” i.e. speaks against Islam and has high profile.  

This reckless behavior brought the condemnation of the FFI members. Of course that information was phony, but he did not know. When he posted that information, he did it with the intention to put my life in danger.  

When our dear Edip Yuksel, the grand Imam of the “reformed” and “humanized” Submitters learned about the incident, at first he thought the information was leaked by a Sunni member of the forum and he strongly condemned it.  He wrote:  

"Exposing" or more accurately unveiling the identity or whereabouts of a person who is out there not to create a personal cult, but to debate important theological issues with great political and social ramification is irrelevant.

But, it is more than irrelevant, it is irresponsi

So, I condemn the acts of those who want to indulge in detective or police work, rather than intellectual debate.

If I want freedom and security for myself, I have to want the same thing for others, including my enemies who are not in act and mindset of physical hostility. To do the opposite is hypocricy.

I believe that Ali Sina's voice, regardless of its truth-value, is precious and should be protected. We cannot find truth without people like Ali Sina.

Personally, I do not care a bit, whether Evilgelical organizations, Zionist organizations, CIA, or any other power pays or uses Ali Sina. To me, it is not relevant and important, since Ali Sina is raising important issues, and voicing important problems with a religion that is followed by more than a billion people.

We are all brothers and sisters from Adam and Eve. We cannot be muslims (submitters to God alone, and men of peace) if we do not act like humans. To be a human, and care about the life of every single human being is a prerequisite of being a muslim. I have no connection with those who ignore and violate this sacred bond among human beings, a bond that was established by our Lord and Creator in the moment and fabric of our creation.

I want people read my position, which I argue with passion that it is also the position of the Quran, regarding the freedom of faith, opinion, philosophy, etc, and their expression.

 

   

Well how can you argue with that? Here our Edip Yuksel, the grand theologian and arguably the ultimate authority of the Sect of Submitters, the group that thinks only they are the true Muslims and other Muslims are misguided and heretics to the extent that they disparagingly call them "Hislamists",  (probably, hadithi Islamists) is reassuring us that he is on the side of the freedom of speech and condemns the “irresponsible and even evil” act of whoever revealed that information. I was so moved with this gesture that I was about to write something praising him for his humanistic stance. But as I checked again I was surprised to find that he had retracted already and in fact he even issued an apology to the culprit once he learned that the person who had tried to get me killed was no one but one of his own sect members.    

Back  <      >   Next

 

Index to this debate 

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Op-ed Authors Debates Leaving Islam FAQ
Comments Library Gallery Video Clips Books Sina's Challenge
 

  ©  copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.