Home

 Articles

 Op-ed

 Authors

 FAQ

 Leaving Islam
 Library
 Gallery
 Comments
 Debates
 Forum

 

 

Comments 

Page 32

 

 

Date:

Fri, 18 Nov 2005 09:57:50 +0530

From:

"Anand" <[email protected]

To:

[email protected]

Subject:

2nd call for debate....

CC:

[email protected]

Mr. Zakir Naik  

This is the 2nd call for debate with Mr. Ali Sina. If you really think that Islam is true religion of god then please reply to me as soon as you can.  

I am sending a copy of this mail to Mr. Ali Sina.... Please Reply To this mail.  

Please give appropriate reason why you don’t want to debate so that all confusions are cleared. As a true Indian citizen I think you will tell the truth and would like to face Mr. Ali Sina.  

Waiting For Your Response..

Regards

Anand

 


 

Subject:

Please Give Your Reply(Both Mr Ali Sina And Mr Zakir Naik)

 Wed, 16 Nov 2005

I am really sorry to know how Hindus are forced to accept Islam in Pakistan . They are really evil.

These announcements make all Hindus and Christians angry but Muslims think that their religion is growing.  

Sir I have read all articles in your website, it is interesting to know that you have proved that Islam is [not] the religion of peace but you haven’t advised or written any article on "what can non-Muslims do to stop this evil" .. Most Muslims in India are not- fundamentalist but peoples like skeleton man are propagating hatred and evil. …So what should I do to sop this evil.........

I passed your link and articles to my Muslim friends but they don’t believe what u say because they themselves don’t know anything about Quran but they think you are also like Zakir Naik i.e. u are doing this for money like Zakir Naik does. All his tapes and books are for Sale NOTHING IS FREE with Zakir Naik. He is not debating with u in wring and insisting to debate in public because of mainly 2 reason  

1) He wants money, money and only money and even if he wins he will sell your tapes to everyone to get money. And as you said he wants 1 million dollars if he wins. If he is really doing something for Islam then why does he need money?  

2) in a written debate he has to give the source of his research i.e. all he writes must be accompanied with concrete proof and that’s impossible for him and he knows that. 

And Mr. Ali Sina doesn’t like public debate with Zakir Naik because of the following reasons... 

1) Ali Sina and all of us know the reality of Muslims and Islam. Imagine a debate between Zakir Naik and Ali Sina in Mumbai, India where Ali Sina has upper hand over Zakir Naik and Zakir knows that he is going to be defeated and suddenly there are 3 explosions in the debate site and 10 bullets pierce Ali Sina's body.

After Ali Sina's death Zakir Naik will say "At last Islam won over kaafirs" 

2) Its not a school debate on "science-- boon or curse" but an important debate which last much longer so instead of having debate in public its much better to debate in writing where nothing is edited and no cheating and no flipping of question like what Mr Zakir Naik does.  

So do you both agree to debate with each other?? 

Please Reply Mr Ali SIna And Mr Zakir Naik... 

Regards

Anand  

 

Dear Anand,  

I already declared my readiness to debate with anyone in writing. As you said scholarly debates are always done in writing. Political debates are usually done face to face. This is not a political debate and I am not running a context of popularity.  

Anyway, forget about Dr. Niak. You and I know that he is not going to debate. He is not a stupid man to risk it all by entering in a debate that he knows he will lose. Try to invite other scholars who are confident of their ability.  

Keep promoting the site. Yes of course the Muslims will be affected. At first they deny and hide their heads in the sand, but eventually they will have to face the truth. The enlightening of Muslims would be like the coming of Spring. At first you see little life but don’t let the appearances deceive you. When the Spring comes you’ll see all flowers blossom at once and everything change. The conversion of Muslims from darkness to light will also happen at once. At this time, we must sow the seeds of truth and don’t expect result overnight. Wait until the proper time and all these seeds will germinate simultaneously. It is not going to be long. It will happen in your own lifetime. You will see the end of Islam. All you have to do now is sow the seeds of truth and wait. 

  


2005/11/16 

Dear Mr. Sina,
 
Sorry for bothering you, but I just wanted to tell you personally how much I admire your site FaithFreedom, and how much I enjoy reading every single line you write. You write with such passion and at the same time with complete clarity of mind, absolutely fantastic! I'm an Israeli musician living in China, and a big fan of Buddhism, I couldn't agree more with what you write, about Islam, other religions, tolerance and intolerance, God, and other issues. I wish you all the best and hope nothing will stop you from continuing your great work, like we Jews say, "live to be 120 years old"! I also hope more people will join you in your thoughts. I'll be sure to speak about and to recommend your site at every opportunity!
 
Your truly,
 
---Oleg

 


 

2005/11/16

I am just a normal human being, if you may say Hindu by beliefs.
I have just one thing to say, that if there is a God indeed, may he bless you and give you more intelligence and wit and power to expose the truth because as it is said in Sanskrit, "satyamev jayate" or truth alone triumphs. Quran also says that the truth stands out free from error.

Though keep one thing in mind, you movement should not end with your death. Keep up this silent revolution and see to it that what you are trying to do should go on and does not die out if you are unactive. Somehow it seemed to me that you alone are doing almost all of the work in this regard.
The most heinous crimes in history have been committed in the name of Islam and most of the Muslims don't even accept it. Who can tell better than a Hindu or a Buddhist who were wiped out from half of the Indian subcontinent. If the Hindu/Buddhist belief survived then there must be something really great in them. Whilst your own Persia , the mighty Egypt and Mesopotamia were subjugated by the barbarians. Thousands of Parsis live in India since they were forced to flee from their homeland 1300 years ago. Still the Muslims don't see anything.

Sometimes I wonder what can make someone go so mad. I remember there was an American called Richard Reid(or maybe he was British), he converted to Islam and then he was trying to blow a plane carrying his own people. In India there was a Hindu boy who fell for a Muslim girl and converted to Islam and was later gunned down by the police for being involved in bomb blasts. He was a nice,educated guy and his father was a doctor and so nobody can say that he did it for money.

Some people say that Islam is so hugely popular because it gives free sanction to animalistic emotions. Maybe to some extent that is true. Still it sometimes beats me how can even such a thing drive someone so insane? Do humans even lose their power to reason? Do they even forget humanity? Does Islam even take away their power of thought?

If God is there, what is HE doing? Is He sleeping ? Why did He let someone create such a vile cult and then let him perpretrate such grave sins in His own name?

Perhaps God is also dead. Who knows. Like humanity, God is also dead.    

Thank you for your email.  

God does not intervene in human lives. Our destiny is in our own hands. It is not true that the truth will always win either.  Truth can only triumph in freedom. Where truth is suppressed falsehood wins.  

No, the movement will not die with my death. It is independent from me and it is growing on its own. Who said I am doing everything? Don't you see so many articles written by so many people and so many friends in the forum helping Muslims to see the light?  I am a soldier. No war will end after the death of one soldier. There are others who will rise up and will carry on. Then again who talked about death? I have no such plans anytime soon. In fact I am very determined to burry Islam and outlast it.  

Keep well and please promote the site.  

Ali Sina


 

 2005/11/15

Dear Dr. Ali Sina,  

It was purely by chance that I stumbled upon your site one day a few months ago and then on I have become an addict to it.  At first I could not believe my eyes because until then I never thought someone would dare think against Islam, let alone write against it for the whole world to see. Would you believe if I say that I was literally shivering when I was reading some of your article - humiliating Muslins – I was looking over my shoulder to make sure nobody was watching me reading! The reason being that I am living in an Islamic country.  

I am a Hindu from India .  I was born and brought up in a remote village in the southern part of India . There were no Muslims in my village around 20 kms in radius. In high school when we were taught Indian history especially the rise and fall of ‘Mughal Empire’, the attack of Sultan Mohd. Ghazni and Babur; plunder and destruction of Somnath temple 17 times, killing and enslaving Hindus, etc.  I wondered how a Muslim looked like. In that tender age, I felt a kind of fear of Muslims and uneasiness about Islam without knowing why. I didn’t even know one Muslim personally. After passing matriculation I went to Bombay (now Mumbai) in search of job. There I met one Muslim and lo! I was wonderstruck; he looked like me, like everyone else.  What was the difference, where was the difference?  

Now many years later, after visiting your site I know the difference, my adolescent fears of Islam stands vindicated. Most people, like me, don’t analyze things and ponder over it; everything is taken on face value. When I observe the terror attacks taking place around the globe the fear of Islam is growing in me day by day. I could be one among the innocents in the next bombing!  

Your writings have convinced me that Allah is Satan himself and Mohammed Satan’s incarnation. No wonder Mo has been selected as number one among 100 most influential human beings lived on earth, the difference being that his influence has been on negative aspects – destructive rather than constructive. He destroyed human values – love, freedom of thought and action for all Muslims, made them zombies.  

I hope your writing will have a positive impact on Indians; but how many of them have internet access.  If 1% of one billion people have access it will be great. And out of those who have internet access, how many knows about your site: faithfreedom? I have no idea. In certain newspaper there is a column for writing comments and I almost always write giving reference to your site with a view to give your message wide coverage. In case you succeed in your mission i.e. destroy Islam, then in India you will be considered an avatar of God. You know, we Hindus, have a habit of worshiping any one or anything that stands out as extraordinary or outstanding in thought and actions. In ancient times one man named Charvaka was worshipped as saint you know for what, he dared to say “There is no God”. You will be remembered forever for daring to challenge Islam. (defeating Islam or not is immaterial).  

By the way I visited some of the pro-Islamic sites and their writings only confirms what you wrote is correct.  

Dr. Sina, congratulations! Keep up the good work.  

Yours sincerely, an admirer  

Kris  

 

Dear Kris. (Sorry, since you live in an Islamic country I changed your name)    

Let us give thanks to the miracle of the Internet and the Yankees who invented such a marvelous thing. I am of course not saying anything new that many others have not said before me. The difference is that now we have the Internet and can say what we want and don’t fear execution.  

It is not just the non-Muslims who could become victims of Islamic terrorism. In fact Muslims are even in greater risk. Everyone could become a victim of Islam and if this war escalate all Muslims could perish. 

Of course we will succeed and of course we will eradicate Islam. But I am already an avatar of God. Aren’t we all? It is a tragedy that most people don’t know it and behave is such depraved ways that they look like avatars of Devil. The Bible says we are made in the semblance of God. There are lots of good things in the Bible. This is one of them. Of course, it is not beseeming for anyone to follow, let alone worship another human being. There is nothing that one has that others can’t find within themselves. I respect Christ and Buddha, but I do not follow or worship them. Instead I try to find that Buddhahood and Christhood within myself. We are all made equal. We are all avatars of God. At times we can act demonic and at other times we can be saints. It all depends on the choices that we make in every instance of our lives. Our souls are like mirrors. We reflect anything, good and bad alike. To what direction we face this mirror is entirely up to us.  If we face it towards the sun, it will reflect light, if we face it to darkness and ugliness it show just that. 

Yes, go ahead and spread the URL of this site as much as you can. Once the truth reaches everyone, we will win this war without ever shedding a drop of blood. In fact we will win it by making friends out of those who have been duped to be our enemies. If we can reach the gullible youth before their minds is poisoned by the mullahs, where the terrorists will find their next victim to become a suicide bomber? This is a victory for all of us. If  we win, no one loses in this war. But if we lose everyone loses.   

Don't worry about those who do not have access to the Internet. Those who have it will tell those who don't and this truth will grow with the word of mouth. 

 


 

2005/11/12

Seven months ago, I believed that Islam was a peaceful religion (I am a Christian and was taught to love and pray for those who persecute you). Seven months ago, I believed Islam was "hijacked" by a few "bad Muslims"...until I came across your website. I was a little hesitant to accept everything at face value on your website, so I decided to do a little research on my own. 

I was shocked to find out that you ARE telling the truth and all of the research I've done supports everything you've said about Islam. I visit your website everyday for updates and have passed the link to friends and family and now they're addicted to this site! 

I just want to say thank you for having the courage to bringing the truth about Islam to the surface for the whole world to see. 

May God continue to bless you and your family. 

Angela  

 

Hi Angela,  

Thank you! I am happy to know so many people are becoming addicted to my site. But keep it a secret. There must be a law against it somewhere. 


 

Hello Mr. Sina,

2005/10/22 

I am a non-moslem Indonesian, but my father is a moslem. So I know a lot about the islamic teaching. It is interesting to say that my father has chosen to give up islam since he says that it is inconsistent. He cannot understand why in one chapter the prophet says not to kill human being, but later in another verse he says that non moslem should be either converted or...killed! My father has many non-moslem friends and he just does not understand why moslem should kill non-moslems if they do not do him any harms. So he left islam and is converted to buddhism. He said that at least he can live peacefully with others now.  

In my country the moslems men are trying to marry the non-moslem girls. At first they are so kind to these girls, but after a marriage everything is changed. Thanks a lot to the facts that many moslem men are indeed not having enough education and therefore poor. It goes well with the islamic teaching that everything is coming from allah so you do not need to do anything. The entire scenario, I think, was failed since the non-moslem girls are far better educated and therefore realize the hidden danger of marrying moslem men. I would like to say that the best way to prevent the spreading of this evil cult is by unveiling its true nature to everybody. I thank you to do that openly in your website.  

Sometimes I think that the best way to prevent the spreading in islam is inventing a time machine, go to the past and poison mohammed! Hopefully it can be done later by somebody who wants to do some good to the mankind.  

candra  

 


 

2005/10/18

Dear Ali Sina 

I am a regular visitor to your site and must say am addicted to it. I read all the articles and have learnt a lot about the true Islam despite knowing much about this evil ideology your site has given me more insight into Islam. But one thing that baffles me to this day. Why have these Islamists left out the South American Continent from their gaze. They have bombed in the US , UK and other European cities, Australians were affected in Bali, they have caused havoc in India , They have terrorised even the Africans (US embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998). Except for one bombing of Israeli Embassy in Argentina a decade ago I cannot recall any other incident. 

Is it just a game plan and a matter of time before some major incidents are planned? Your views will be highly appreciated. 

Regards 

Sami

 

There are not many Muslims in South America. You see terrorism only in countries where there is a substantial number of Muslims. The bombing in Argentina was done by the Iranian government and it was aimed at the Israeli Embassy Argentineans were not the target. Why Argentina? Because the Israeli Embassy there, was less protected.

 


 

]2005/10/16

Dear Dr.Sina

 
Congratulations for this site, wish you best of luck. I am now an addict to your site. I am an Arab with a sunni muslim background. For many years I thought I am alone in my thoughts, now I know there are many others like me. It is frustrating that people like me cannot openly speak their minds. 
I like your courage and optimism. I do not know if I can help but I am happy to help. 

Salih 

Dear Salih: 

I am happy you found us. Yes there are many of us and everyday more people see the fallacy of this cult and leave it. People like us existed throughout the history. Since they could not speak freely, they often thought they are alone. Now, thanks to the Internet, we can learn about each other and share ideas. You can help by spreading the message and helping others. We have quite a few Arabs in our group. You can start an Arbic site. Now we have a dedicated server, courtesy of the friends and supporters of FFI. We would be glad to give you a free space to start your own site with your own domain or as a subdomain of faithfreedom.org  


dear faithfreedom.org


I Manoj kumar from india, is a daily reader of your site. I got imense knowledge about muslim faith and i am satisfied that I am not a muslim. Its very sad that muslim people dont undersatand the logic, there is a veil on there eye which can only be lift by site like yours faithfreedom.org.I have read amny muslim site also but i am very much convinced with your logic and your proof. In the last I want to highlight the plight of kasmiri  pandits or hindu due to muslim terrorism, on your site becuse it is widely read by europeans as well as american. they are feed with lies that indian army is doing bad things ,but as a indian i know Indian army is most humanistic army in worlds, they dont like killing.There are one millions of hindu in kasmir valley before the start of muslim terrorism, now they are only hundreds in kasmir.Its a matter of study for western media (they are bised against india)  how a million people can leave there ancestor home (kasmiri pandits have a living history of more than 5000 years in kasmir valley) and become a refugie in there own country.They are raped ,murdered and fatwas are anounced from the masjid that they should leave kasmir or face death.this is called genocide or ethenic cleaning but no western media as well as secular and communist media of inida highlight there pligh. Its shameful for humanright NGO who take care of rights of terrorist but not the common kasmiri hindu  who are victim of terrorism. PLEASE dr Ali Sinha highlight the cause of kasmiri people who are terrorised by muslim terrorist supported by pakistan. It may be last plea from a kasmiri people who are gonig to loose every thing after starting of dialouge between India and Pakistan becuase they are not the party with whome talk is going to happen. Indian govt is talking to terrorists and pakistan but not the kasmiri hindus (original inhibitnat) At last Please highlight our  cause to international community ,It  may be my last plea for internatinal community       

manoj 

 Back                               Next  

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Op-ed Authors Debates Leaving Islam FAQ
Comments Library Gallery Video Clips Books Sina's Challenge
 

  ©  copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.