Scholastics vs. Scouts
A response to Dr. Alireza Assar and Celine Leduc
by Ali Sina
Dear Mr. Sina;
I have recently seen your
anti-Islamic propaganda on internet.
You claim that your life was threatend because you turned
away from Islam. I just don't believe your claim; may be it is
because you are doing all you can to fight against Islam that your
life is threatened and not only because you are not a moslem
anymore, for which I don't think anybody bothers to threaten you.
Dear Dr. Alireza Assar:
Yes I know, many Muslims in the West leave Islam and
as long a they do it silently no one is going to hurt them. However, as
you can see, I am not very silent about it.
|I am the brother of Dr. Farhad
Assar, and although I don't completely support his rather hard
views, I must confess that I don't understand you at all!!!
Why any person should spend so much time and effort to fight
Why not? Islam is the curse of humanity. Every day people are being blown
up to pieces because of it. A billion people are caught in the grip of
dictatorship, poverty, ignorance and perpetual wars and misery because of
it. Half of humanity’s rights are trampled and because of their “wrong
gender” they are abused. The whole world is in danger of destruction in
a nuclear holocaust because of Islam. What is more important than saving
mankind from certain destruction? What cause is nobler than this?
Do you claim to be a new
Yes I do. I chose to become a prophet. I discovered
my own prophethood when I understood the nobility of man and fathomed his
potential. I am a prophet unto my own self and to nobody else. We humans
are born noble and free. It is not dignified for us to follow another
person, especially if the claims of this person are farfetched and his
character villainous. We must find our own way, with reason and
commonsense. We have the tools to do it. All of us, unless we are mentally
handicapped, have an inner compass with which we can find our way. It is
not becoming of us humans to follow someone else blindly. What if this
person is a charlatan? What if this person is a psychopath narcissist like
Muhammad, Hitler, or other dictators and cult leaders who seduced many and
brought death and misery upon so many people? It is foolish to be a
follower. There is a danger in being a follower. All the wars were caused
because humans gave up their own rational thinking and followed blindly
someone else. Of all the wars that have taken place in the history of
mankind, none happened between two democratic nations. In all the wars, at
least one side has been a dictatorship. In dictatorships people are not
free - they are followers. The nobility of man is in his freedom. When you
take away the freedom of someone you take away his nobility. The worst
slavery is the slavery of mind. You can be in fetters but if you are the
owner of your thoughts you are a free man. The word noble in Persian is
azadeh, which literally means free. A noble man is a free man. Muhammad
took that nobility away. He said humans are slaves. I want to restore that
nobility and show that he lied; break those shackles of mind that he put
on his benighted followers and set them free. Yes I am a prophet and my
message is don’t believe, doubt everything, do not be a follower but a
prophet unto your own.
|Are you proposing anything new
worthy of listening to or you just want to be considered?
Those who come to this site and read my articles have
decided that what I write is worthy of reading. Our message is the
remedy for most ills of mankind. What is worthier than making humans
discover their nobility and their freedom of thought? This is what sets us
humans apart from animals. This is the strength we need to get rid of
dictatorships and not to fall prey in the net of lies of charlatans and
false prophets. This is a simple message but very profound. We can change
the world, we can get rid of all dictatorships, all wars and all miseries
if we discover our nobility, became prophets unto our own and not blind
followers of impostors. In this simple message lies the key to human
freedom, prosperity and happiness. What message is bigger than this? What
cause is worthier than this?
No, I do not do this just because I want to be
considered, nor I do this because of my "childhood trauma" or
any other silly excuses you Muslims have come up with to placate your
conscience, avoid heeding to my message, and horror of horrors, THINK.
These are ad hominems, attacks at the messenger and not logical
responses. I want you to discover your own nobility and become free. Don't
consider me, go and consider yourself.
Because Muslims are not free, because they act
motivated by faith and not by reason, and because they follow a
psychopath, they have become zombies. They are a threat to others and to
world peace. They are killing the rest of us and are threatening to blow
up the world with atomic bombs.
There are only few choices in front of us: 1) join
them and become barbarous like them, which means constant wars and
bloodshed, which means the end of civilization and culture and which means
the world become like Iran, Saudi Arabia or other Islamic countries where hoodlums
and thugs rule. 2) Do nothing and let them kill us or subdue us and become
their slaves; or 3) kill them before they kill us. These are not very
pleasing choices. There is a forth alternative and that is to set them
free from the spell of Muhammad, exorcize that demon from their
hearts and minds and revive their humanness so we all can become friends
and see one another as members of one human family. We, who bring the
message of FaithFreedom to you, have chosen the latter path. But if we
fail, option three is the default.
Muslims must realize that their insanity is not going
to bear fruit. The lies of Muhammad, like the lies of Hitler are just
lies. They will not succeed but fail and they will die by millions. The
Muslims' monomania is bringing the world to its destruction. Islam is
insanity and produces nothing but insane people, who are filled with hate
for no reason and think of nothing but death - murder of others and
martyrdom for themselves. This is a macabre religion. When the president
of the Islamic Republic of Iran says "Israel should be wiped out from
the map" and he is pursuing his diabolic plans to get hold of nuclear
bombs, only a fool cannot see the world is in great danger. Of course
Israel and the free world will not wait until this mad man realize his
demonic wish. But the oppressed people of Iran will pay for this madness
and innocent people will die. This stupidity must end and this
site plans to do just that.
Dear fellow I find
notying worthy in your writings against Islam.
I am a Physicist and a Mathematician for years; I have taught
in many Universities and Institutes around the world Including my
during 1984-1990. I have my own scientific and philosophical
thoughts about religions and faith. I believe you must study more
and talk less, since I really believe that your arguments are not
worthy at all to be considered by serious academicans.
Merry Christmas and happy new year;
As a university professor and a person who has his
own scientific and philosophical thoughts you said nothing factual here.
All you said is that I don’t know anything. That is not a logical
argument but an opinion informed by spite and not by reason. What do you
mean by my writings against Islam not being worthy? Do you mean they are
not logical? Am I not giving enough proofs? Are my proofs faulty? In that
case you have the chance to prove me wrong and refute whatever you think
is worthless. Are you up to this challenge? Can you show my errors? When I
say Muhammad was a conman and a charlatan I give proofs. What are your
proofs about my writings being wrong?
Worth is subjective. What to you seems worthless, to others may seem
valuable. But facts are conclusive. Facts rule. I have proven factually
that Muhammad was a liar. Can you prove factually that I am wrong?
You flaunt your academic titles and yet you fail to
give one single logical argument to refute me. This is called argumentum ad verecundiam, which is one of many logical fallacies.
You want us to take you for your word because you claim to be an
authority. Truth must stand on its own not because someone authoritative
says so. There are also other university professors with scientific and
philosophical thoughts that do not believe in Islam. Shall we check the
diplomas of the proponents and the opponents of Islam to see whether Islam is
true or false? This is an absurd argument for a university professor. If a
proposition is true, one must be able to prove it irrespective of who is
in favor of it and who is against it.
Thank you for your trite advice to “study more”.
I study every day. Everyday I am learning something new. I question my
understanding and challenge the conventional beliefs. I do not accept
anything unless it is proven as fact. This does not mean I will reject
anything that is not proven yet, but I simply doubt it until it is proven.
What about you? What are the logical bases of your
belief in Islam? Can you prove that Muhammad was a prophet of God and not
a liar? I have proven that he was a psychopath narcissist. Can you prove
me wrong? Your claim that my arguments against Islam are not worth
refuting is another logical fallacy. A site that has so many readers is
worth refuting. The fact that you dislike this site is not a valid
argument to dismiss our charges against Islam. I despise Muhammad and yet
I do not hesitate to show he was a liar. It is not for him that I do it.
That fiend is dead, his fetid corpse has rotten and his soul is burning in
Hell. I am doing it for those who are alive and are caught in his web of
lies. If you have evidence that what I say is false, you have a moral duty
to prove me wrong. Do it
for millions of people who come to read what we say and may believe in our
“lies”. No my friend, it is clear the reason you do not even attempt
to refute our claim is that you know you can’t. So you find it easier to
throw a stone and run than roll up your sleeves and come to the ring to
fight man to man. Any argument, no matter how fallacious, merits to be
refuted especially if it is believed to be true by many.
| 2 next