Comments 

Page 31

2005/10/12

Sir, thank you for providing this wonderful site (faithfreedom international).You may not know what role you have played in delivering me from the grip of deception I want to use this medium to tell you that you have really saved me. 

Before, I used to believe that Islam was a religion of peace and made a lot of sense. As a result I found myself on the verge of converting to Islam. Some of my friends who heard me say Islam was a religion of peace thought I had gone mad but could not convince me to believe otherwise. However, some few months ago I came across your site and reality dawned on me like sunrise; the scales of ignorance fell off my eyes. Since then I now know better. 

However, my main purpose of writing you is to draw your attention to some articles on faithfreedom.com namely; Exposing the teachings about the so-called unbelievers and who are the unbelievers Mr. Sina presents as non-Muslims. In these articles, they claim you take most of those verses out of context. I have read much of your articles since you advise us to read your articles before asking questions or making comments and can’t find answers to their rebuttals. Maybe you have answered them but I don’t know. If you have, could you kindly show me where? If you haven’t, I can’t wait for your response.

Thanks.

Emmanuel 

Dear Emmanuel,

I am glad to see you saw the truth before wasting your life in this cult. Now it is your responsibility to help others so they don’t fall in this trap. Promote faithfreedom.org  Just as this site helped you, it can help millions, but we have to reach them.

As for faithfreedom.com folks, they had some debates with us when they first started their site. The link to those debates are at the top of my debate page, so no one can miss them. Have they published those debated in their site? No! …Why? …Ask them!

Also when they first started they were so confident of themselves that they even had a guestbook. People started writing in their guestbook and asking questions. Soon they realized the guestbook is not a good idea and removed it.

Yes all their claims are answered. If they think something is not answered, they should post their rebuttal in the forum of this site so someone can answer them. Unlike them, we have an open forum and we invite the Muslims to be active and actually become the majority. We don’t practice censorship (unless someone acts unscholarly, like insulting other members, spamming and doing other things that are frowned in any decent society). So what stops Muslims to come to our site and become the majority? We would love that.  

2005/10/12

have read some of your site with interest.  I am a Christian, but my brother recently married a Moslem.  (I have no intention of becoming Moslem myself, and I agree with your comments about the eroticism of the whole female figure by Islam.  I have seen how that works for myself when visiting my new sister in law's family.)

Assuming that all you say is true, how do you propose to 'eradicate' Islam?  I find such a suggestion highly offensive, to be honest, and smacking not a little of fascism.  Is it the thinking that you aim to eradicate, or the people?  I think this needs to be clarified in what you say if you want to attract the moderate, thinking person, and not just the young and impetuous.

It strikes me that, as they stand, your words are just extremism from the other side, and every bit as dangerous as the opinions you quote from Islam itself.

I have not posted this in public because you may prefer to consider this issue privately, rather than in public. 

Cathy

Dear Cathy,

Islam is an ideology; it is not people, so how anyone can interpret the eradication of Islam as extermination of people is beyond me. When we say we want to eradicate malaria, cancer or illiteracy, are we saying we want to kill the patients and illiterate people? I think this is self explanatory and it does not require any further elucidation. Furthermore I am a Persian and all my people are Muslims, would that make sense for me to say I want to kill all my relatives, kit and kin? I am surprised that you even ask such question.

Islam must be eradicated and there is nothing fascistic about it. If you decide to eradicate racism, Nazism or KKK, can anyone accuse you of being a fascist or a hate monger? Would that person have any credibility?  When you call a person who strives to eradicate a doctrine of hate like Islam a fascist you are committing the same logical fallacy. There is nothing wrong in fighting evil. In fact if you don’t fight evil and tolerate it, you become part of it. If you are a good person, you should fight evil and since Islam is evil to its core, you must fight it. You should not tolerate intolerance. Good people must stand strong against Islam and do everything they can to eradicate it. Those who don’t can be divided in two groups: a) those that don’t know Islam and therefore tolerate it out of ignorance, or b) those who are themselves evil. During the 1930s some people realized Nazism is evil and opposed it. They were the good guys. But a great majority of people did not. They wanted to make peace with the Nazis. This lead to Hitler becoming strong and as the result 60 million people lost their lives. Those who did not oppose the rise of Nazism could be divided in two groups. One group were the idiots and the other group were the evil people who were the enemy itself. The situation with Islam is no different. Those who do not oppose it are either ignorant about the true nature of Islam or they are the enemy itself.  

How could your brother marry a Muslim girl? Did he have to convert?

2005/10/11

Dear Ali  

it is several weeks that i discoverd your site and through it i am in contact with others similar sites.  

i am moroccan and live in italy , and like you my paradise is what my life is now , a good italian husband and two beautiful children without imposing on them any kind of cult.  

i watch arabic channels and have muslim friends. i notice that societies and mentalities are changing . they ask for a secular islam what i want to say is that it will be impossible to eliminate islam, but it would be possible to reform it  

i know that for you islam cannot be reformed. i am not looking for saving Islam, i am living happily without it. i am just looking for an optimist solution  because i do not beleive that one day this religion will be eleminated  

sorry fo my bad English if you understand italian , let me write you in italian  

aisha  

Ciao Aisha,  

I think the revers is true. It is impossible to reform Islam but it is possible to eradicate it.    

If one believes that Muhammad as a prophet of God, then one has to accept all the stupidities and the violence of the Quran. How can you reform Islam without eliminating the Quran?  

On the other hand once you prove that Muhammad was not a prophet of God but a charlatan liar, Islam disappears and with it all the problems that is has engendered.  

Yes I understand Italian. You can write in Italian if you like, although your English is very good.  

Keep well  

Ali Sina

Dear Ali Sina, 

I'm writing to tell you that I come to your site now and then, and still find it hard to believe you're actually a Muslim; well ex-Muslim. I say this cause it's rare to find Muslims intelligent like you and honest about Islam. I've known some Muslims in my life and my experiences with them weren't the greatest. Though I personally have no hatred towards Muslims because I don't believe in hate...the fact remains that most Muslims are not tolerant and accepting of non-Muslims (or even fellow Muslims), or anyone that honestly challenges Islam. The only exception is as you said if they're not deeply religious. I have my close friend who is a Muslim and he's a dear friend, but when it comes to politics and religion I always need to be careful with words if you know what I mean. However, he's I guess what one would say a "secular" Muslim if there is such a thing. My point is that I've been exposed to the Islamic religion and Arabic culture (actually going to a Muslim country myself) and fear that most people are largely ignorant about the reality of Islam i.e. it is not a tolerant religion. I hope people will open their eyes and see the truth for themselves; especially Muslims. This doesn't mean they need to convert but Islam needs major changes in its teachings if it wants to better it's reputation in the world. I believe that Islamic teachings, until the present, have been seriously corrupted with false, evil, and dangerous teachings. I have read the Qur'an and wanted to find bits that would allow be to believe that it's respectful of non-Muslims and a peaceful religion, but unfortunately I didn't find much of this. The Qur'an to me was uninspiring, repetitive, inconstant, intolerant, and much of the content was taken from Christian and Jewish teachings. I also don't understand how Mohamed is seen as a great prophet. Perhaps he was a prophet in his own right but cannot be compared with Jesus. Although I respect and tolerate Muslims I know that the reverse rarely applies. I hope you can reply to my e-mail. 

Regards.

Sabrina  

Dear Sabrina.  

Thanks for your kind words. Have you read the articles written by other ex-Muslims in this site? Don’t you agree that they too are honest and intelligent? The reason Muslims are not honest is because they are following a cult. Cultists are dishonest and this is not exclusive to Muslims. They become so brain washed that they no more can distinguish the right from the wrong and they believe all vices become good if it is for the advancement of their faith. Their thinking becomes so twisted that the first person they try to fool is themselves. They lie to themselves and fool themselves and that is why you don’t see them as honest or intelligent. Other wise they are honest and intelligent like the rest of people. Only in matters of their faith they are dishonest and dumb.  

As for Islam being corrupted that is not true at all. Islam has been a corrupt faith from the start. Islam does not need reform, it needs eradication. Would you suggest reforming KKK or Nazism? What is there to reform?  

Muhammad was not a prophet. He was a cult leader. To understand Islam, you have to read about cults such as that of Jim Jones, David Koresh and Shoko Asahara. Only then all the pieces of the puzzle fall into place and you can answer all your questions about Islam.  

I have compared Islam to the cult of Jim Jones. Take a look. You will be surprised to see the similarity.  

 http://faithfreedom.org/Articles/sinaawa20.htm  

Please advertise the site.  

Kind regards  

Ali Sina

 Back                               Next