Justifying One Fallacy With Another
By Ali Sina
A Letter from a
Dear Ali Sina,
I read some of your
comments about Islam which I found very intriguing and draconian
at the same time. I agree with some of what you said about
Islam, but my question to you is, what about the other
monotheistic religions, Judaism and Christianity?
Donít you think that
Islam built on those two former theocracies? After all most, if
not all, of the Quran corroborate the bible, old and new
testaments. The stories or the folktales, religious rulings, hatred
of people, vengeance of God, wars on others beliefs, hellfire
for others, and many more concepts in the Quran are found in the
Next donít you think
that today the religious zealots in
are ruling with hegemony that equals to, or exceeds, the Mullahs
of the Muslim world, therefore they are as dangerous as the
Muslim Mullahs. You see, the Jews invented the idea of one God
and the rest is history.
Please reply I am very
interested in you comments
You are right in the sense that
the Qruan is plagiarized from the Bible. Ibn
Warraq has a book titled The Origins of the Quran and he shows how
basically all the Quranic fables were taken from the Old and New
Testaments and the pagan lore of the Arabs.
And you are also right when you
say the Old Testament is also full of absurdities and violence. Muhammad
was inspired by that violence and it was this accepted violence in
religious thinking that did not shock the Arabs when Muhammad started
his sadistic pillaging and murdering in the name of God. Obviously this
mentality has not changed. Even today you find people who are so
brainwashed that are not bothered about the violence in these so called
holy books and Muslims commit violence on daily basis and preach them in
Muslims immediately justify the
violence of Muhammad and his book with the violence of the Bible. Their
brain is so shrunk that it does not occur to them that may be all these
books are false and none of them is from God.
If the Quran is plagiarized from the Bible and the Bible contains
fallacies absurdities and violence, it does not make the Quran a book of
God. It makes the Quran equally a false book. We must not justify the
violence of the Quran with the violence of the Bible but rather reject
all of them.
However, I totally disagree with
you when you compare the Jews and the Christians of today, no matter how
zealots they may be, with the Mullahs. This is obviously not so. If you
live in this planet and are not secluded in a cave you should know that
90% of terrorisms are perpetrated by Muslims. I do not see any Jew
strapping bombs to his waist and exploding himself amidst a large number
of people. I do not
see anyone slitting the throat of another human being and shouting
"Jesus is great". The acts of violence reported in the Old
Testament are fables of the past. Much
of that is fabricated by priests such as Jeremiah and Ezra and may
not be true at all. Even if they were, they are stories about Moses and
Joshua and that is not what the average Jews or Christians are supposed
to do. But the violent teachings of the Quran are binding on all the
Muslims and they apply to all times. Jiahd which means killing the
non-Muslims and forcing Islam on them with acts of terrorism is a pillar
of Islam. There is no similar injunction on the Jews, Christians or
That is why the Judaism and
Christianity do not produce terrorists unless you are a nutcase and go
shooting the abortion doctors. But that is an exception and not a norm.
However, anyone who reads the Quran and believes in it has no other
option but to become a terrorist.
Yes the Quran is a plagiary. Yes
monotheism and the concept of a jealous and narcissist god is the
invention of the Jews, but that does not exonerate Muslims to follow
the evil cult of Islam. It does not matter who invented this fallacy.
Muslims are responsible for believing in it, for practicing it and for
bringing death and destruction to the world.
If you know all of this madness
is based on a cult of a bunch of ignorant Jews with archaic beliefs and
primitive minds then stop it now. Moses
was not a monotheist. He believed in many Gods while claiming his
god was the most powerful. This is clear from
Psalms 82 where the psalmist talks about the assembly of gods
and Jehovah presiding over them. The concept of monotheism was invented
by the rabies of the 7th century BC to control the
Jews and foster in them the sense of nationalism. Monotheism was born
out of political exigencies of the Jews.
Who cares if the Jews or the
Christians still want to believe in absurdities? At least they are not
killing people for their faith. They are not endangering the peace of
the world. Let them believe in what they like. But Muslims are killing
people in the name of their god. They are rolling this planet into an
abyss. Islam is not just a false religion. It is a dangerous religion.
You and I must stop it before more lives are lost and before we too are
This is not a race of stupidity.
We are not competing with Jews and Christians to prove that we are the
most idiots of mankind. If the Jews and Christians want to believe in
their foolish religions, let them. They are not killing people. Muslims
are. And this is the problem.
I urge the Muslims to read this
site and ponder. If you canít prove me wrong please leave Islam and
help others leave it too. Islam is not a religion of God. It is a cult
created by a psychopath. You will not please God if you follow an evil
man such a Muhammad.
Islamís days are over. Sites
like this are sprouting all over the Internet and in all languages and
Islamís ugly face is being unmasked. People of the world are seeing
Islam for what it is and their tolerance of Islam and Muslims is coming
to an end. Have pity on your soul and on the lives of innocent children
born in Islamic countries. The followers of this mad man are dragging
the world into a war in which they will be annihilated by millions. If
you have any humanity in you, if you have any decency and brains, it is
up to you to investigate what we say about Muhammad, prove us wrong or
Islam is a danger to mankind but
the danger does not come from a book, it comes from people who believe
in that book. Do not assume that since you have not slit anyoneís
throat you are innocent. By being part of this machinery of
terror you are just as guilty as others who commit these dastardly acts.
In an army not everyone is in the frontline fighting -- some work in the
kitchen, some sew the uniforms, some manufacture the bullets but all of
them are working together for the same cause. As a Muslim you may not be
involved in acts of terrorism but you provide justification for the
terrorists, your Zakat is spent to finance terrorism, your apologies
rationalize their actions, and your presence gives them moral support
and validation to their crimes against humanity. You are by all means a
part and an ancillary to this machinery of terror and are responsible
for what your brethrens do. If you are a decent person, if you are HUMAN,
leave Islam and stop this insanity.
Look at the Americans. Some of
their soldiers humiliated a few terrorists and thugs and all of them are
now full of rage. Compare that to the reaction of the Muslims for the
brutal killing of the four American contractors and the cowardly
beheading of Nick Berg. Where is the Muslim outrage? There is none.
There is only justification and excuses. And yet the humiliation of the
Iraqi prisoners is nothing compared to what these murderous Islamists
did to innocent people while shouting Allahu Akbar.
Yes Americans are not saint.
They are also guilty of many wrongdoings. But there is a huge gap between
the level of humanity of American public and that of Muslims. Those Muslims
who committed such crimes are not humans and those who support them and
justify their actions are also not humans. They are animals and not just
any animal like cats and dogs that are noble animals but hyenas, rattle
snakes and scorpions.
I am in touch with the people
all over the world and monitor their sentiments. Let me tell you that
the patience is wearing out. When these people realize their kindness is
interpreted as weakness and their tolerance is abused, they will react
and the reaction will be extremely painful.
Do not let that happen. Do not
count on the humanity of these people. After all when it comes to
survival we are all animals underneath. You do not want to see the
animal side of these people. Do not push your luck. It is enough with
insanity. It is enough with mindless killing and savagery. Do not act as
if you are the victims. Muslims are victims of their own stupidity. They
are victims for following a psychopath. Get to your senses now and save
your life and the lives of millions of people before it is too late.
Get out of Islam now. Islam is
not a religion of God. It is the cult of a psychopath. You
can't reform it. Just leave it. If you get out
and if most of the Muslims get out, the terrorists among you will
realize that they do not have your support and they will stop their
insanity too. It is your support that feeds their frenzy but at the end
you lose. You lose everything. Do not let the Armageddon come to pass.
Leave Islam. Do it now. Tomorrow
may be too late