The Muslims’ Captivity to their Tragic History

Jacob Thomas

Consultant on Middle Eastern affair/ Columnist

4 Responses

  1. Ram says:

    @Maarifeislami,
    Here are the answer for your blabbering or queries point by point.

    ”My Dear! the Muslims were neither the terrorists nor had the Tragic history ,
    this is your arrogance about Islam , if you want to know the real Islam.”
    You are wrong here. They were worst than the terrorist (i.e Jihadi) and thats how they spreaded their violatant ideology called Islam.

    ”Try to know the Hussein (pbuh) and His father Ali(Pbuh) better and must read about their sacrifice and martyrdom.”

    What was this martyrdom for? Definitely it was not for spreading the good or superior human values but for getting a succession of a political power.

    ”If You have read about them and still you have not understand them i request you to go to karbala next coming Arbaeen you will observe the reality and purity in Islam.”

    What is there to see? Can,t you explain to us so that we can benefit.

    ”If you are not ready to do that i think you are just the servants of America and Israel and you are only here deceiving and misleading the people by your crazy talks and evidences. we don’t discuss with their Agents.”

    This is arrogance. No one is begging to you for intellectual discourse and it is foolishness to expect a honest discourse with Muslims because they might retort to violence to opponent. This is my personal view.

    ”If you accuse the Muslims of being terrorists let me ask you :
    1. who started the 1st World War? was it Muslims?

    2. who started the 2nd world War? was it Muslims?”
    Muslims caused more damage to the world civilization than the world 1 and 2 put together even in recent times. Even in the history they were killing…killing… and raping to others as well as themselves. What do you think how they subjugated and converted the Persions, Egyptians, Pakistanis, Afganis, Indians, Bengladeshis and many more nationalities? by love and peace? Of course not. but by killing, plundering and raping. Moreover this question is irrelevant here because in those war who were the enemies at that time they have become friends. They do not carry the baggage of history today. But Muslim carry the baggage of history. Thats because the bigotory is packed in religion called Islam. Since they have the cover of religion thats why the ignorant people think that like other religions Islam also is a religion but in reality it is not.

    ”3. who killed about 20 million of aborigines in Australia?was it Muslims?
    4. Who drowned the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki?was it Muslims?
    5. who killed millions of people in North America? was it Muslims?
    6. who killed people in South Africa ?was it Muslims?”

    I have partly answered it above. But for your satisfaction again these acts which were commited in the past have no baggage of history today. There is not discrimination in the countries who have supposedly done it. I.e an aboriginal in modern Australia have the same right as others, Japan and America are not frozen in history. In Africa Muslims are killing others even in the moment I am typing.

    ”7.who took about 180 millions of African people as slaves. of whom 88% died and were thrown in Atlantic Ocean? was it Muslims?”
    Even If I assume that this happened in histrory there is no present day slavery in the nations you are accusing. But Muslims are doing it even today. They are selling the women as cattles. Even the so called prophet of Islam-he used to have slaves. But not other religions prophets.

    ”8. who bombed the Iraq and after killing the Thousands of people , they excused and said sorry we made mistake?”
    Even they said sorry when they have realized. But Muslims have not realized their mistakes. Forget about the sorry.

    ”9. who created Daesh ?”
    This is a good questions to Muslims to ponder over.

    ”10. who is killing the Palestinians and who provide the weapons to Daesh. was it Muslims?”
    It is the Palestinians who are stabbing Jews and launching the rockets to Israel. Turkey and Saudi Arabia are providing all the logistics and weapons to Daesh.

    ”Give me the answer of these Questions i know you can’t you are only to bark here like a loyal dog for his lord (America)”
    I had given the answers to your queries. If you are not satisfied then tell me where I am wrong and I will try to correct myself if I am satisfied by your arguements.

    ”But let me tell after all this harassment the Islam will coverup entire world one day, this is the promise of God.”

    YOU HAVE REVEALED YOURSELF HERE. FINALLY YOU HAVE SPELLED THE ROOT CAUSE OF ALL THE PROBLEMS IN TODAY,S WORLD AS WELL AS IN THE PAST.
    by the I am not the same person to whom you have asked the questions. I was just surfing through and I notices a Jihadi.

  2. Richard says:

    @ maarifeislami
    Of course no-one is saying that every ba thig that ever happened was the fault of Muslims.

    However you seem to be misinformed about several of your points.

    “who started the 1st World War? was it Muslims?”
    They were certainly heavily involved in that war – and were at least part of the cause. Also they committed a genocide during and immediately after it

    “7.who took about 180 millions of African people as slaves. of whom 88% died and were thrown in Atlantic Ocean? was it Muslims?”

    Actually YES – Muslim slave traders sold the slaves out of Africa to the Europeans – at the same time they were capturing europeans as slaves in the mediterranean.

    “9. who created Daesh ?
    10. who is killing the Palestinians and who provide the weapons to Daesh. was it Muslims? ”

    pretty much yes – and the only reason that the muslims don’t actualy make the weapons themselves is because they have always had to rely on others for the technology.

  3. My Dear! the Muslims were neither the terrorists nor had the Tragic history ,
    this is your arrogance about Islam , if you want to know the real Islam.
    Try to know the Hussein (pbuh) and His father Ali(Pbuh) better and must read about their sacrifice and martyrdom.
    If You have read about them and still you have not understand them i request you to go to karbala next coming Arbaeen you will observe the reality and purity in Islam.
    If you are not ready to do that i think you are just the servants of America and Israel and you are only here deceiving and misleading the people by your crazy talks and evidences. we don’t discuss with their Agents.
    If you accuse the Muslims of being terrorists let me ask you :
    1. who started the 1st World War? was it Muslims?
    2. who started the 2nd world War? was it Muslims?
    3. who killed about 20 million of aborigines in Australia?was it Muslims?
    4. Who drowned the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki?was it Muslims?
    5. who killed millions of people in North America? was it Muslims?
    6. who killed people in South Africa ?was it Muslims?
    7.who took about 180 millions of African people as slaves. of whom 88% died and were thrown in Atlantic Ocean? was it Muslims?
    8. who bombed the Iraq and after killing the Thousands of people , they excused and said sorry we made mistake?
    9. who created Daesh ?
    10. who is killing the Palestinians and who provide the weapons to Daesh. was it Muslims?

    Give me the answer of these Questions i know you can’t you are only to bark here like a loyal dog for his lord (America)
    But let me tell after all this harassment the Islam will coverup entire world one day, this is the promise of God.

  4. John says:

    Very nice brief history of Islam. Informative. Islam is at the core of the problem. Causes divisions, war, disunity, instability and terror in the world. It must be addressed soon and eradicated to make a world a safer place to live without constant horror of terror done majority by Muslims adherent of Islam.