Reformation of Islam”: a supplementary exposition. Do We Really Need it?

Praying Imam

6 Responses

  1. amit says:

    sufism is peaceful version of islam? sufism is a soft tool used to convert non-muslims into islam. kashmiri king Rinchan was converted fraudulently into islam, thus giving inroads to islam in kashmir. another example is third battle of panipat in which sufi saint Shah Walliullah invited sunni Ahmadshah Abdali from afghanistan to Destroy hindu marathas & loot & Plunder Punjab and was Shamelessly supported by Shia Shuja of Awadh. they were Supported by najib khan rohilla and the baloch.if sunnis, shias and sufis are different how cum they three formed alliance against hindu marathas who were only defenders of punjab & North India?. Sufism is nothing but al Taqqiya or deception . the baloch took 20-25 hindu maratha prisones of war to baluchistan.baloch supported abdali and destroyed punjab ,which is now torturing baloch . this is cycle of karma.

  2. Marcello says:

    well said

  3. Richard says:

    I do take issue with one point in the article.
    “What about Christianity, a religion older than Islam? Did it not progress from its extremely violent past to acclimatize to the contemporary way of living? ”

    No that is not what happened. Christianity started off as an entirely peaceful religion. In the 4th century it was given a gift it did not really seek by the emperor Constantine. The history of the following 1700 years in Christianity has been the struggle against the temptation to use violence. Christians have often failed in that struggle but as it has gone on the civil authorities in Christian lands have gradually become less violent.

    Because Christianity is not, at root, built on violence is is comparatively easy to remove the violence from it.

    Islam – on the other hand has a problem because without the violence there is little left – and what there is is not unique to Islam.

  4. Marcello says:

    Reform and change in Islam is impossible. Any reform,change , and any effort to make that happen is considered “Blasphemy” and “Apostasy” that are punishable by death.

  5. Walter Sieruk says:

    As for the idea of “reforming Islam ?” If that can be done the good. Go for It. Nevertheless , in the case of reality, the idea of”reforming Islam” is only a pipe-dream and a fantasy. For the very essence of Islam of deceitfully demonic . For there is nothing that is really good about Islam that can be used a foundation which is build real reform on. First, as for the doctrinal error of Islam there is a Christian site that replies to the many clams made by the apologist for Islam. It’ Second, apart from that, the daydream of “reforming Islam”i s sheer folly. For already stated the firm base of real, actual reform is not contained in the essence of Islam. As the Bible teaches “That which is crooked cannot be made straight:and that which is wanting cannot be numbered.” Ecclesiastes 1:15. [K.J.V]

  6. ali says:

    great article.