|
Attention: Year 2009 is here
Wishing a very Happy New Year to all members of FFI. Our new and improved site is ready. To visit main site, click at faithfreedom.org and to visit our new forum, click at forum09.faithfreedom.org and register again. Do not worry about your old forum posts and PM, everything is saved here till 31st December, 2008 for future references.
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| reletomp wrote: |
you are counting match/mismatch.
i am counting match/one step mutation numbers (1 or 2 or 3 one step mutations) |
They are all assumed to be one-step mutations, reletomp.
| reletomp wrote: |
21 of the jews are in the CMH 6/6.
but 23 jews are outside 6/6 but in the cl0se cluster.
you can not count MRCA ignoring the cluster!!! |
??? The MRCA is calculated using the cluster. You cannot calculate the coalescence time by ignoring the cluster. It is the cluster that permits you to calculate the number of generations from the MRCA. The coalescence time to MRCA considers the cluster because it is based on a mathematical formula that takes account of the mutations around the MODE to derive the COALESCENCE TIME.
As the time from the MRCA is 106 generations, according to Hammer et al., some proportion of the population will deviate from the MODE due to GENETIC DRIFT. That's why you'll find Jews carrying mutations around the CMH Mode.
We expect the Jews to show dispersion around their mode. Not every CMHg Jew will carry CMH. Some will carry CMH.1 and a small proportion will carry even more dispersion. However, the proportion of them carrying CMH and CMH.1 is very high compared to the Arabs as can be seen in this graph (data taken from Nebel).
Here is the distribution around CMH - data taken from Nebel.
Jews Arabs
CMH 21 3
CMH.1 7 3
CMH.2 4 18
CMH.3 5 28
What this shows is that the Arabs and the Jews possess different haplotype MODES. The Mode for the Jews is CMH, while the Mode for the Arabs is CMH.3.
Thus, the Arabs have a DIFFERENT MODE - because they split earlier. They also deviate around their own distinct mode. This Arab Mode is 3 mutations from the CMH Mode, which can only mean that the Arabs diverged from the Jews long BEFORE the first Cohanim.
Think of a population as a NORMAL DISTRIBUTION. There will be overlaps between two related populations like the Arabs and the Jews. However, the divergence of these two populations is derived from the differences between their MODES.
Remember that Hammer et al. worked out the MRCA of the Cohanim to be 106 generations - i.e. 2800 to 3300 years, based on a mutation rate of 0.0021. If the mutation rate was 0.004, this coalescence time would halve to 53 generations - i.e. Aaron would live 3 to 4 centuries after Jesus.
Therefore, this proves beyond doubt that if we accept this theory, we must use the mutation rate of 0.0021 or thereabouts. I have already shown you several scientific proof that the CMH mutation rate is around 0.002. Not 0.004.
With a mutation rate of 0.002, this means that the Arabs diverged from the Jews 308 generations before the first Cohanim. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
Here is the distribution around CMH - data taken from Nebel.
Jews Arabs
CMH 21 3
CMH.1 7 3
CMH.2 4 18
CMH.3 5 28 |
you never give up cheating don't you.
this is the table:
=======Jews=Arabs
CMH ------- 21 ----3
CMH+-1 ---13----- 21
CMH+-2 --8 -----24
CMH+-3---- 5----- 28
CMH+-4/5 --6 -----9.
you can see they are mixed together:
see Nebel:
www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1274378&rendertype=figure&id=FG5
displays an MJ network relating all 47 haplotypes of Eu 10, representing 133 chromosomes of the sample. The CMH occupies the central position in the network and is connected to eight haplotypes, suggesting that it was at the core of expansion of the Eu 10 lineages in the populations studied.
www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1274378&rendertype=figure&id=FG3
Figure 3
Simplified network relating the five modal haplotypes found in the six Middle Eastern populations. The haplotypes are defined by alleles at six microsatellite loci in the order Lines between the haplotypes represent single-microsatellite mutation steps. The frequency of the modal haplotypes in each population is shown. AJ = Ashkenazi Jews; SJ = Sephardic Jews; KJ = Kurdish Jews; PA = Palestinian Arabs; B = Bedouin; MK = Muslim Kurds; MH = modal haplotype; and CMH = Cohen modal haplotype. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
What are you talking about?
My numbers for the Arabs DON'T CONTAIN Bedouins. You are not Bedouin. The issue is not the Bedouins, but the so-called Palestinian ARABS.
You have misrepresented your image:
The pink are Palestinians and Bedouins together. We aren't interested in Bedouins.
Palestinian Arabs are THREE mutations away from the first Cohanim - going backwards in time. Not forward in time. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 1:53 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| reletomp wrote: |
| Quote: |
Here is the distribution around CMH - data taken from Nebel.
Jews Arabs
CMH 21 3
CMH.1 7 3
CMH.2 4 18
CMH.3 5 28 |
you never give up cheating don't you.
this is the table:
=======Jews=Arabs
CMH ------- 21 ----3
CMH+-1 ---13----- 21
CMH+-2 --8 -----24
CMH+-3---- 5----- 28
CMH+-4/5 --6 -----9. |
Let's check your numbers:
CMH.2
These are the CMH.2 Haplotypes that pertain to Palestinian Arabs.
Haplotype & Number
144 = 12
152 = 3
160 = 1
166 = 1
171 = 1
Total = 18. Where did you get 24?
I think you have screwed up your calculations. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 2:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
what about the Negev Bedoin, they are palestinian arabs.
So now bedoin are not arab?
even with out the bedoin Palestinian arabs are 12 not 3 in the CMH+-!, where did you come up with the 3 only??
in CMH+-2 Palestinian arabs Arabs are 18 and in CMH+-3 PA are 24.
The CMH is mainly in Kurdish jews not Ashkenazim or Sephardim (10 CMH in Kurdish jews and only 5 in Sephardim jews and 3 in Palestinian Arabs and 6 in ash jews) if it was not for the kurdish jews CMH would not had been specific to jews.
I did not count muslim kurds J1 even though they are mostly arab gene flow into kurds.
if you look at the network map you see 1/3 arabs in the CMH+-1, another third in the CMH+-2 and a last third in CMH +-3 (3 to 4 one step mutations are allowed fora time span of 3500 years)
hardly no population exist in the CMH+-5 or +-6 etc, indicating the MRCA of CMH cluster lived recently 3500 years ago.
Only Ethiopians and some christian lebanese have cluster away from CMH (semites frm before the time of Abraham) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| reletomp wrote: |
what about the Negev Bedoin, they are palestinian arabs.
So now bedoin are not arab? |
We're talking about the Palestinian Arabs who claim Israel/Palestine. I don't care about the Bedouins.
| reletomp wrote: |
| even with out the bedoin Palestinian arabs are 12 not 3 in the CMH+-!, where did you come up with the 3 only?? |
Your numbers still show that the Palestinian Arab Modal Haplotype is 3 mutations from CMH, and hence you PAs diverged from the Jews long before Abraham.
Haplotype 147 = 2.
Haplotype 162 = 1.
Where did you get the 12 from?
| reletomp wrote: |
in CMH+-2 Palestinian arabs Arabs are 18 and in CMH+-3 PA are 24.
The CMH is mainly in Kurdish jews not Ashkenazim or Sephardim (10 CMH in Kurdish jews and only 5 in Sephardim jews and 3 in Palestinian Arabs and 6 in ash jews) if it was not for the kurdish jews CMH would not had been specific to jews. |
???
Haplotype 159 (i.e. CMH)
So? Kurdish Jews are still Jews.
| reletomp wrote: |
| I did not count muslim kurds J1 even though they are mostly arab gene flow into kurds. |
Seeing that there is only 1 muslim kurd that carry CMH, it wouldn't make much difference.
| reletomp wrote: |
| if you look at the network map you see 1/3 arabs in the CMH+-1, another third in the CMH+-2 and a last third in CMH +-3 (3 to 4 one step mutations are allowed fora time span of 3500 years) |
???
How can this be when Nebel showed these numbers:
Palestinian Arabs only:
CMH.1 = 3
CMH.2 = 18
CMH.3 = 24
I think you don't understand how to read the network map. Each box isn't 1/3. They don't provide info on numbers of people - just the number of step mutations from CMH.
| reletomp wrote: |
hardly no population exist in the CMH+-5 or +-6 etc, indicating the MRCA of CMH cluster lived recently 3500 years ago. |
????
How did you calculate that? Seeing that the mutation rates of each of the DYS's are different - there are three very very slow mutators in there - you wouldn't expect CMH.5 and CMH.6. This shows your lack of understanding of human genetics. It's a pity you only know how to use AVERAGE numbers without understanding the details.
Here are the mutation rates again:
Y7976 ysearch.org Chandler
DYS19 0.001548 0.001453 0.00151
DYS388 0.000379 0.000245 0.00022
DYS390 0.004405 0.00532 0.00311
DYS391 0.003155 0.004145 0.00265
DYS392 0.001488 0.001587 0.00052
DYS393 0.001119 0.001434 0.00076
This is the same table converted to per generations.
Y7976 ysearch.org Chandler Average
DYS19 646 688 662 665
DYS388 2639 4082 4545 3755
DYS390 227 188 322 246
DYS391 317 241 377 312
DYS392 672 630 1923 1075
DYS393 894 697 1316 969
You can see DYS388, 392 and 393 are very slow mutators. Even DYS19 is not very quick.
So in about 3000 years, i.e. 106 generations, why would you expect to see CMH.5 and CMH.6? You already mutated from CMH to CMH.3. The mutation profile is ASSYMETRIC because of the assymetric mutation rates.
| reletomp wrote: |
Only Ethiopians and some christian lebanese have cluster away from CMH (semites frm before the time of Abraham) |
This is irrelevant. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 10:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
| We're talking about the Palestinian Arabs who claim Israel/Palestine. I don't care about the Bedouins. |
if you wanna take out the J1- Bedoin Arab you should take out j1-Kurd Jews, because the J1 in Kurds more likely gene flow from Arabs!!!
hence the table become like this:
=======jews Arabs
CMH-------11----3
CMH+-1----7---12
CMH+-2---4----17
CMH+-3---0----24
CMH+-4---5----7----------
hence, no statistical significance in this table, they are all mixed up in all haplotypes, even jews are high in CMH+-4!!!! (another peak)
| Quote: |
How can this be when Nebel showed these numbers:
Palestinian Arabs only:
CMH.1 = 3
CMH.2 = 18
CMH.3 = 24 |
where did exactly Nebel say this?
I recommend you go through every haplotype in the J1 table (Eu10) and count one step mutations in each and see how many arabs in that haplotype and how many jews! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 7:30 am Post subject: |
|
|
well?
check mate it is then.
There was no need for all this running around for 100s of posts.
Like I said, the j1- CMH cluster (ie up to 4 or even 5 one step mutations haplotypes) is the signature of Abraham progeny (the Arabs (400 million people) and the very little tiny portion of Aaron survivors through cohen line in Jews (1% of 12 million people jews worldwide),
and that all the rest of the jews (99% of them) are not descendents from Abraham at all (not through father line and not through mother line)..
Conclusion:
The governmentof Israel is illegal and their giving citizen ship papers to worldwide jewry is also illegal (the Semitic Law of Return of 1949 of the illegal state of Israel), even the rabbies who dispensed the citizenship papers by way of mother or grandmotherjewishness, are also them selves not descendents of Abraham (again not through mother or father line).
Palestine has always been inhabited by the descendents of braham (the Palestinians) who were deported and ethnically cleansed from their country Palestine: the Holy Land or Israel Land if you will).
Britain, The World Jewish Agency and UN and League of Nations before the Rockefellar paid UN on Manhatten Island) are wrong and did wrong to the Palestinians that they should compensate them and return them to their homeland the promise of YHWH to Abraham progey (the Palestinians). |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 9:13 am Post subject: |
|
|
What is clear is that the mutation rate for CMH must be around 0.002 if you want to claim that the first Cohanim lived around the time of Aaron.
With this mutation rate, the Palestianian Arab Modal Haplotype, being 3 mutations different from CMH, means that the Palestinian Arab MRCA must have lived about 300 generations BEFORE the first Cohanim. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 7:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
What is clear is that the average of all studies abount mutation rates cline toward .004 or .003 as in Ystr.org www.ystr.org/index
If you average the mutation rate for the 6 TRs of CMH in the Ystr.org it is exactly .003
One fast STR can neutralise 2 or more very slow STrs easily.
IN CMH at least one STR is very fast.
in any combination of STRs one STR is fast enough to neutralize any combination of slow STRs.
For example a slow STR can ot go under .000000. but a fast one is upto .07!!! or even .7 for some ( avearage mutation rate is .003).
The CMH cluster range is narrow very narrow (3 mutaions wide containing 95% of all the sister haplotypes as you saw in the MJ netword map above.
this means the CMH cluster is recent not old.
recent as time of Abraham , not old as time of brancing of J1 8 thousand years ago.
you can not also divide the cluster into two clusters one for cohanim and one for arab. because the cluster belong to Abraham ot Aaron. and because you can not divide it period.
Again the conclusion is that millions of arabs are in the CMH cluster of J1 while only few jews are in it.
The reason Thomas et al 1998 and Nebel 2000 and 2001 had high levels in Ashkenazim Israelite, is because the sample of Cohanim Ashkenazim of Hammer 1997 was reused as Ashkenazim in general.
But now only .03 of all jewish men have both J1 -cmh and j2-cmh, making the J1-cmh barely .012 ofthe total population of jews( ie 1.5% of the contemporary jews descend from Abraham and the rest are fillings)
while the Arabs and particularly the Palestinians are 80% J1 (all of J1 of arabs are in the J1-CMH cluster)
making 80% of Palestinians direct descendents of Abraham ( and Isaac Jacob too, since the jews at time of Jesus half of them became known as christians and continued to become the current palestinians! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ramon22

Joined: 18 Jan 2007 Posts: 130
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 4:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
Arabs and the Jews are cousins from one father Abrahim (SAW) its a fact you dont need books or dna to prove that just ask a real Jew or an Arab, the Jews you see in Israel are not related to the Arabs cause they are euro trash that adopted the Jewish faith, its funny that people are coming to realize this now, its shocking right cause Arabs and Jews are related that makes them by CHRISTIAN standards half Gods cause they have the same blood that your God has jesus(pbuh), right or wrong
so Saddam must have been like Hercules or something like that, cause it took all the world to power up against him.
forget this triple nonsense, no man is better then the other only by his deeds, let the Jews think they are better then the rest of the world , thats what the devil thought as well.
for more reading go Jewwatch.com also to
jews for allah |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 5:12 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
| Arabs and the Jews are cousins |
Arabs and ancient jews are cousins.
Arabs and Contemporary Jews are not cousins.
Current Arabs are children of Abraham, and current jews are children of Magog ( and children ogf persians and cushites and phut and etc of betrayers of their corresponding nations, because they refuse to live among their nations: Ukraine, Beloruse, Russia, Poland, ethiopia, Persia, kurdia, Hun-garia, Khazaristan, Kazakhistan etc).
Their existance in the Holy land is anti-god action. Because god assigned this land to his children ( arabs and jews: the original jews became arabs after conversion to christianity and islam)
and so for the die hard christians who want to get blesses by the children of Abraham, stop the genoside against the palestinians you created (Balfour Declaration, British conquest of Jersalem in 1917)
and send some money and food to the True children of Abraham in Gaza city West bank and where ever the palestinians are refugees now a days (because of you) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ramon22

Joined: 18 Jan 2007 Posts: 130
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 5:47 am Post subject: |
|
|
| reletomp could not agree with you more, but to bad people seem to want to live in a fairy tale were Arabs be it Christians or Muslims are seen as evil and the so called Jews are the chosen people,but again this is the age of lairs and cowards |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
reletomp

Joined: 05 Mar 2008 Posts: 962 Location: usa
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 8:35 am Post subject: |
|
|
I am just making fun of things. I don't believe any body is promised.
but those devil advocates on TV are making a killing asking for 20 dollars contribution to the blessed people chosen people of the so called Nation of Israel (meaning the magoggite khazars who named their illegal state ISRAEL!?
to make fun of the world and decieve them into giving their money to them.
but the people who need help of samaritans are the poor Palestinian people who been under seige embargo and starving in their own homeland, hated just because they are named ! Palestinians (ie the Filistines who faught David )
I am just exposing the lies and expecting no help to the palestinians from those monkeys, just to make a point
Monkeys are meant : Benny Hinn, Lahey?, Hagay?, Shamroukh, Shlominsky,ben Khorion, and many more |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cassandra

Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4495
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 11:43 am Post subject: |
|
|
| reletomp wrote: |
What is clear is that the average of all studies abount mutation rates cline toward .004 or .003 as in Ystr.org www.ystr.org/index
If you average the mutation rate for the 6 TRs of CMH in the Ystr.org it is exactly .003
|
Your mind is a sieve.
Hammer et al. 2000 estimated the Cohanim MRCA to be 106 generations based on a mutation rate of 0.0021.
Therefore, mutation rate 0.0021 ==> 106 generations ==> 3,3300 years.
IF YOU CHANGE THIS MUTATION RATE TO 0.003
The Cohanim MRCA must have been 106 / 0.003 x 0.0021 = 74 GENERATIONS
This means that 2310 years ago AT THE MOST.
This means Aaron lived 300 years BEFORE Jesus.
You are being ridiculous. Do not change the mutation rate if you want to continue to rely on Hammer's hypothesis.
| reletomp wrote: |
One fast STR can neutralise 2 or more very slow STrs easily.
IN CMH at least one STR is very fast.
in any combination of STRs one STR is fast enough to neutralize any combination of slow STRs.
For example a slow STR can ot go under .000000. but a fast one is upto .07!!! or even .7 for some ( avearage mutation rate is .003).
The CMH cluster range is narrow very narrow (3 mutaions wide containing 95% of all the sister haplotypes as you saw in the MJ netword map above.
this means the CMH cluster is recent not old.
recent as time of Abraham , not old as time of brancing of J1 8 thousand years ago.
you can not also divide the cluster into two clusters one for cohanim and one for arab. because the cluster belong to Abraham ot Aaron. and because you can not divide it period.
Again the conclusion is that millions of arabs are in the CMH cluster of J1 while only few jews are in it.
The reason Thomas et al 1998 and Nebel 2000 and 2001 had high levels in Ashkenazim Israelite, is because the sample of Cohanim Ashkenazim of Hammer 1997 was reused as Ashkenazim in general.
But now only .03 of all jewish men have both J1 -cmh and j2-cmh, making the J1-cmh barely .012 ofthe total population of jews( ie 1.5% of the contemporary jews descend from Abraham and the rest are fillings)
while the Arabs and particularly the Palestinians are 80% J1 (all of J1 of arabs are in the J1-CMH cluster)
making 80% of Palestinians direct descendents of Abraham ( and Isaac Jacob too, since the jews at time of Jesus half of them became known as christians and continued to become the current palestinians! |
This is childish nonsense. No YSTR can 'neutralize' another. I've looked at the YSTR.org site - where are your numbers. I even quoted the real to you. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|