"Mosab Rayan" <[email protected]>
Sun, 15 Apr 2001
I have read the reason why you left Islam and other articles and I can easily
conlude that your are very ignorant in Islamic Law or Jurisprudence.
About Ahadiths (Sunnah):
Their are alot of false and weak ahadith and according to Shariah Law, the
authentic can only be legitimate, such as Sahih Bukhari.
All the hadiths that I quoted are from Bukhari and Muslim and I gave the
references. If you failed to even check that
how objective can you be in judging the rest of my articles?
“Not all Islamic rulings can be implemented at any given time and
place. For example, the law of the cutting of the hands and feet due to
theft, can not be implemented on society, until society has reached close to
spiritual perfection (which is not the case today), and the reastablishment of
the Islamic leadership (The Khilafah or Caliphate, which was destroyed in
Can you prove this by quoting from Quran or is it something that you made up?
Who gave you the authority to pass such ruling? The problem with Islam is that
in the course of it 1400 years of history any idiot has tried to re-interpret
the Sharia and propose ideas that are not found in Quran. That is why Muslims
are divided in so many sects. Your opinion is worthless unless you can back it
up by Quran, which you can’t.
Their are many examples like the one just mentioned. In Shariah, their
is an order and way in how to implement specicifc rulings in society.
Since the Islamic Nation (Ummah) has lost the leadership (the Khilafah), we
are not in the position to implement certain rules, whether foreign (towards
non-Muslims, such as the Jizyah Law or Protection Fee) or domestic (towards
Muslims, such as the penalty of adultry or theft).
Whether you can or cannot implement the Islamic laws is irrelevant. The point
is that these laws are barbaric in any time. Islamic laws are primitive and
backward and wherever they are practiced that place has become a hell on earth.
Examples: Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, etc. The more a
country is Islamic the higher is its index of human right abuse and barbarity.
According to a neutral perspective, it is a very well known fact by
non-Muslims and Muslims that the Arabic Qur'an (not the English Transalation
of the Meaning of Qur'an), is indeed 'extra-terriestial', that is, it is
impossible for it to be of human source. So we can conclude that the
Qur'an was Divinely reaveled to humanity.
You can fool yourself as much as you wish. I read Quran in Arabic and found it
tremendously poor and bereft of any beauty. It is an extremely disorganized
book and has plenty of grammatical, historical, scientific and logical errors.
The English translators have tried hard to hide the brutal and savage language
of the Quran. For example when Muhammad says beat your wives if they are
disobedient, some translators like Yusufali have added the adjective “lightly”.
This lightly does not exist in the original Arabic. There are many cases like
this. If you knew Arabic and could read that book in the original language you
would not have defended it so blindly. Who said that piece of garage is “extra
terrestrial?” This is the stupidest lie that Muslims keep telling themselves
for over a thousand years. I checked it out for myself and found that it is a