With unbound rage Mr
Hasan (purportedly from
) impugned me with extreme vituperative (NFB,
January 7, 2004
). In my essay, ĎOn the Making of an Unbeliever (NFB,
January 6, 2004
), I delineated a few aspects of Islamic faith which, when a believer
contemplates very deeply, might force him/her to leave Islam. In his
extreme diatribe Mr Hasan called me a liar and asked me to show him the
proof of some of those Islamic provisions.
may read Mr Hasanís response attached at the end of this reply]
Here is my response on
To severe the
tie of kinship with the infidel parents and siblings:
am quoting from the Holy Qurían a few verses which tell us clearly that
a convert to Islam must not be friendly to the immediate blood-relations
of him; viz. his parents and siblings.
father, brothers are not protectors; believers should not be friendly with
009.023 YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! take not for protectors your fathers
and your brothers if they love infidelity above Faith: if any of you do
so, they do wrong.
believers should not take even their fathers, brothers, or sons as friends
if they resist God and Muhammad; these types of believers are the party of
God, that is, the believers cannot be friendly with the unbelievers even
though they are their blood relations... 58:22
058.022 YUSUFALI: Thou wilt not find any people who believe in Allah and
the Last Day, loving those who resist Allah and His Messenger, even though
they were their fathers or their sons, or their brothers, or their
kindred. For such He has written Faith in their hearts, and strengthened
them with a spirit from Himself. And He will admit them to Gardens beneath
which Rivers flow, to dwell therein (for ever). Allah will be well pleased
with them, and they with Him. They are the Party of Allah. Truly it is the
Party of Allah that will achieve Felicity.
and children are not to obey each other if either party warships other
029.008 YUSUFALI: We have enjoined on man kindness to parents: but if they
(either of them) strive (to force) thee to join with Me (in worship)
anything of which thou hast no knowledge, obey them not. Ye have (all) to
return to me, and I will tell you (the truth) of all that ye did.
not obey parents if they ask you to worship other than God...31:15
031.015 YUSUFALI: "But if they strive to make thee join in worship
with Me things of which thou hast no knowledge, obey them not; yet bear
them company in this life with justice (and consideration), and follow the
way of those who turn to me (in love): in the end the return of you all is
to Me, and I will tell you the truth (and meaning) of all that ye
are a few more verses from the Holy Qurían that indirectly tell Muslims
to avoid the friendship of infidels even though they could be their
not take unbelievers as friends; caution is necessary to befriend the
003.028 YUSUFALI: Let not the believers Take for friends or helpers
Unbelievers rather than believers: if any do that, in nothing will there
be help from Allah: except by way of precaution, that ye may Guard
yourselves from them. But Allah cautions you (To remember) Himself; for
the final goal is to Allah.
not be intimate with the unbelievers; they will hate you and ruin
003.118 YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! Take not into your intimacy those
outside your ranks: They will not fail to corrupt you. They only desire
your ruin: Rank hatred has already appeared from their mouths: What their
hearts conceal is far worse. We have made plain to you the Signs, if ye
friends are God, His apostle (Muhammad) and the fellowship of pious and
005.055 YUSUFALI: Your (real) friends are (no less than) Allah, His
Messenger, and the (fellowship of) believers,- those who establish regular
prayers and regular charity, and they bow down humbly (in worship).
be friendly with the disbelievers; they are Godís enemies...60:13
060.013 YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! Turn not (for friendship) to people on
whom is the Wrath of Allah, of the Hereafter they are already in despair,
just as the Unbelievers are in despair about those (buried) in graves.
(Muhammad) more than one's parents, children and even mankind...1.2.13, 14
The Prophet passed by me at a place called Al-Abwa
or Waddan, and was asked whether it was permissible to attack the pagan
warriors at night with the probability of exposing their women and
children to danger. The Prophet replied, "They (i.e. women and
children) are from them (i.e. pagans)." I also heard the Prophet
saying, "The institution of Hima is invalid except for Allah and His
During the night of raids the women and children
of the polytheists can be killed Ö19. 4322
Now now, what do we have here indeed. Lets seeÖ hmm itís a postingÖ
a posting in which you thought would inspire many of us misguided
"fundamentalist" to become non believers in a god. A mail in
which you thought would show the rest of us that we have a right to be
embarrased of our heritage and religonÖ hmm... Why donít we have a
look at what you saidÖ.
You start your mail by talking about the Biswa Ijtemain
. Yet you ignore the fact that these countries are corrupt mainly by the
secular leaders. Crime at the majority of the time is commited by
disbelivers in an afterlife or people who have no morals or those who do
not think that they will be judged. You therefore have shown that in these
least developed muslim countries itís the bad people who are on top not
You then claim Arabic is the language of Allah. As far as im aware Allah
knows all languages and every thing that is in existence. Arabic for your
information is not the languague of Allah it was the language of the arabs.
And of course infidels are going to have it better its because this is
there paradise. However your forgetting the blessing of the entire muslim
world Allah has bestowed on them, in the example of providing them with
oil, gas plentiful of natural resources which many countries lack. Had the
muslim ummah followed the religon properly, poverty would not exist in the
muslim world, had they followed the law of God properly we woud be under
the khillafa and it would be the most powerful force on earth. This is
and the rest of the non believers or so called anti islamic named muslims
They fear that the islamic state concept will distrupt
and the west influence on the world and are therefore using the likes of
you and everything else to thrawth it. Obviously people fighting for the
islamic revolution to come back understand this, and areÖ... But hold on
I shall stop this sentence here as I know this may cause you and others on
this board many sleepless nights, so I will Shsssssssh here and not
disrupt your sleep!.
You then go on to talk about floods. Hmm but when a country is corrupt
is not surprising for floods to take people away. If the country was an
proper established islamic nation, we would not have the corruption
problems we face today and would be able to deal with these natural
disaster matters. But then again I doubt you would ever understand this,
as your knowledge on islam from what I read in your mail is quite poor.
But then again the problem is you may not understand how if a person
drowns he is considered as shaheed. Obviously because you cling onto this
life so much your concept of dieing is a scary one!.
You may think that individual who has drowned is at a loss yet in Islam
he/she has gained a wonderful life. For example he/she may not have the
chance of being misguided by those corrupt mullahs or by the likes of you
and other secularist. He/she has escaped the problems of life and is at a
better place. Maybe this is something you will never get but hey I cant
blame you. You seemed persecuted and a non believer in a god. Yet the way
the world has been created may have never entered your head and just like
in the belief of God may seem ridicolous by you, so does the scientific
theories on the creation of mandkind and the universe.
You talk about
the shia nation. If the two cases are true then surely itís the so
called "mullahs" who did this injustice will also face simillar
punishment in the afterlife. Oh but then you may not believe in that, you
may think you will come back recarnated into an rat. So I better not scare
you any furtherÖ.as london has a huge rat population, they say theres 2
rats per person in the country, I shall be kind to not step on them when
travelling on the underground.
You then go on to talk about killing children is in Islam. Please PROOVE
your lie. Children and women are protected in JIHAD. What happened in
BESLAN was terrorism. In fact the true story of that disaster would never
be known. The fact that you think such is possible by Islam shows how
closed your mind is and how immature your mentality is. I think you been
Quite interesting on your claims of tablique jamat. Although I do not
follow tablique beliefs, I do have to say you have again fabricated a lie
where you talk about them sanctioning the Dar ul Harb concept. I know for
a fact they donít. Maybe the people you know were messed up. Maybe you
attract those type of people because of your own nature. Maybe you seek
these types of people because you yourself have never seeked the truth and
have placed yourself amongst these people.
Maybe you have the problem? Ever thought of that? I mean quite tragic that
you have been persecuted in believing these thai girls were allowed for
pleasure. I am trynig to think, on this trip was were you gay at any
point? Cause boy if I didnít believe in a god id go for a thai massage
as well!! I hear they are quite umm interestingÖ. Bit strange how you
kept away from that stuffÖ Boy you must have been gay or have some will
power!... You see I donít understand how you can consider a person is
practising Islam if they have sex in brothels.
Quite confusing mind you have there.
You then go on about being ashamed of telling someone you cant drink.
Maybe your next thing is that you should be ashamed of being a bengali
because your regarded as the "miskeen" by the rest of the world.
Maybe your future generation will be white skinned helped by you marrying
a white girl so you donít have to have your brown skin interferring with
your embarrasement of what you were born. Maybe you have a problem with
your whole origin and hate being who you are. Maybe you just cant handle
what you are and feel inferior to the super white race. And maybe your
ashamed as you have no guts to stick up for a belief that you may have
had. Hmm sounds a bit like the Hitler propaganda here.
You then talk about terrorism in
, and how these terrorist are killing people. Because you havent got a
white skin and you have a muslim name you then talk about how you try to
hide your face from your neighbours because you donít like the way you
was born. Because of your cowardness to stand up against these terrorist
in the name of Islam, you rather hide away and say im not a muslim because
I am being judged for the action of others. But maybe if thatís the case
then itís a problem with the others and not yourself. Maybe they should
be aware that muslims do not believe in this and that those acts are as
barbaric as the pilot dropping a bomb on a mosque or a school where many
children and women are blown apart! Maybe when your in that situation and
your mum, your dad your siblings and even children are taken away you can
sit there and say, O America, How I love you america!...
You then again fabricate lies, by saying how a muslim son has to disown
his parents. Ermm right, so all the reverts to Islam in the world disown
their parents do they? Quite interesting lie you have said, considering
that the non muslim parents still have rights on a muslim son. The muslim
son still has to RESPECT his parents and as long as they donít force him
to do haraam, such as forcing him to drink. Regardless of how they are the
muslim son still has to be kind to them .You then talk about the Hujur
beating the student. Yes well obviously in developing countries this will
occur. Solution is education that this practice should be abolished. But
hold on!!! The country is corrupt!!! How do we get the message across!.
The people who are on the top and who donít believe in Islam are too
busy filling their own pockets! They donít have time for the country do
they? They donít have time to educate the masses to they, nah instead
they have time to sing amar sonar bangla! Thatís ok! As long as that
happens we bangladeshis are alright, wouldnít be surprised if the next
statement is Jai Hind.
You then talk about the arabic name. Well bengali names have moved a bit
from arabic name as we donít have their system practiced in bangladesh
im sure your not the "bin" or "ibn" of your fathers
name. In fact we are following the western surname concept so this prooves
you wrong again.
You seem upset of the toilet habits as well and the hygiene, of course
your western friends who donít wash their hands in the toilet or wipe
the A$$ are much cleaner than us. But of course they just contract sexual
diseases, typhoid and other stuff much less donít they?. But maybe you
donít like the cleaniness of the religion. Maybe you like to be dirty or
your into smelling your own production because the western clean white
skin makes up for all the dirt. Maybe its psychological problem with your
skin colour, you feel being brown means being dirty so being white and
dirty seems better?
You talk about the workers sent there to work in the streets of arabia.
Talk to the companies who send them there exploiting many of these
workers. Talk to the bengali uncles living it large in
on these poor souls working in these corrupt regimes. Blame our dynastical
families for being so corrupt and not putting their foot down on their
abuses. Just like every bengali, money rules, these arabs pay them off and
they shutup. Ever thought why the pakistnis are now being treated better
in the arab states?.
You again talk about your inferiority complex of being brown the tragic
brown colour, or shall I say the stuff that comes out of your backside.
You talk abot people considering arabs superior to you, even though Islam
says everyone is equal. Because of your own messed up mind and inferiority
complex you then question your faith due to your own misunderstanding of
race and due to your love of the white colour.
I would say a person with this type of life seems quite tragic. I think
you yourself have been trully tramatised. I can see that you have lied
quite a bit on the religon. Tut.. Tut.. naughty naughty. I think you need
help from a shrink. It seems you have not just a problem of your religion
you was so wickedly born into (blame your parents, id say) but also your
did the full shabang, why donít you just become a rich doctor and do the
Maybe then you can rid yourself of your bengaliness and I wouldnít have
had to waste my precious time responding to your joke
Of course there is another solution. You may try taking some pills, and go
to the other side. I am sure then your questions and doubts will all go
Thanks to the advent of the Internet, people are also able to respond
(currently gonna go and enjoy some Halal Lunch in a "dingy"