A plea to Sina from a Muslim...
A response to Faisal Siddiqui [email protected]
By Ali Sina
Your proof is
nothing more then rambling, you distort history, you give false and misleading
account of facts, you misrepresent a persons life.
In that case you should have no problem rebutting me. Indeed for Muslims
proof is nothing but rambling. For the thinking people proof is everything. They
accept the claim of a criminal to be a prophet and demand no proof. Where is the
proof that Muhammad was whom he said he was?
If I distort history or anything, it can be easily demonstrated. Where is
your proof? Show me exactly which things I have distorted and what is your
evidence. I have shown the distortions in the Quran, why can't you show the
distortion in my writings? I quote the Sira, the Hadith
and the Quran to prove Muhammad committed mass murder of the Jews who
never fought against him and whose only crime was to be wealthy and not want to
believe in his bogus claim. Is this distortion of the truth? Do you have any
other version of history? Show me your evidence. I say Muhammad raped women
whose husbands he murdered in his raids. Or he tortured people in the most
sadistic way before killing them. I quote Islamic sources to back my claim. Is
this a lie? Can you show from your own history that such things did not happen?
I am sorry you donít believe in proofs. This makes you vulnerable to reject
the truth and accept any falsehood.
Since you and I
were not part of history there is a probability that it happened for reasons
Islam says and there is a remote possibility it happened for reasons you say,
but there is no 100% guarantee that you can say for a fact what you are
saying is the truth but I have faith in what I am saying is 100% true and a
You and I don't have to be part of history to know the history. We have the
same sources to rely on and those are the Sira, the Quran and the Hadith. The
Islam we know is the Islam taught in these books. If you want to doubt these
books which Islam you believe? The one which is the figment of your imagination?
My problem is with the Islam taught in these book. I don't care what you
believe. Maybe Muhammad also is just a fictitious personage. Maybe everything is
concocted by a bunch of Arabs to expand their Imperialism. You
canít have your cake and eat it too. Are these books true or not? If they are
true, then Islam is evil. If they are false, then what Islam? This is just a
lie. Why follow a lie?
Islam does not
say worship my Prophet (PBUH), it doesnít say take him as the son of god, it
doesnít say take him as your saviour, it doesnít say without him there is no
salvation, it doesnít say he is god, it simply says 'there is no God but GOD
and Muhammad is the Last messenger of God' - now how does translate into
Muhammedism - for the simple bigot Christian - I do not know. Now what part of
the above doesn't get into your thick skull?
Forget about the Christians. I am not a Christian and I donít have to
answer for them. Muhammad did not say worship me because no one would have
followed him. No cult leader would say worship me because he will not be
believed. They all claim to be the messenger of God and then demand obedience
and respect because they are the only representatives of God. The Quran is full
of exhortations of Muhammad demanding his foolhardy followers to obey him. If I
want to fool you, I will never say I am God worship me. You will never do that.
But I can fool you and say I am a messenger of God and now do as I tell you.
That is much easier to do.
So Muhammad did not say there is no salvation without me? How do you
interpret these verses?
9:66, Make ye no excuses: ye have rejected Faith after ye had
accepted it. If We pardon some of you, We will punish others amongst you, for
that they are in sin
Those who turn back as apostates after Guidance was clearly
shown to them, the Evil One has instigated them and busied them up with false
We will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve, because they
set up with Allah that for which He has sent down no authority, and their abode
is the fire, and evil is the abode of the unjust.
And prepare against them what force you can and horses tied at the frontier, to terrorize
thereby the enemy of Allah...
I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore
strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them.
How do you explain the fact that Muhammad raided innocent
people, killed them and forced them to convert or die?
1 | 2
| 3 | 4