Sachar Committee Report Uncovered Backwardness of India’s Muslims, Part 1
Submitted by Dr Radhasyam Br... on Tue, 03/24/2009 - 02:29
Printer-friendly version
Send to friend
PDF versionBy: Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
The Backwardness of the Muslims is Ubiquitous:
To brainwash the Muslims, the mullahs always say to them that in the entire world, only the contents of the Koran is the pure words of God and the Muslims are lucky to possess the most up to date message of God. But the question remains - Why the Muslims, despite having the pure as well as the latest message of God, are so backward? When my article "Influence of Prophet Muhammad and the Quran on Incest in Muslim Societies" appeared in www.islam-watch.org on 15 Feb, 2009, a reader raised this issue and commented, "If islam is so good , then why Muslims are so bad? Why Muslim countries are so backward and ignorant? Why they spawn, terrorists, pirates, criminals of all hues? Why is Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan ,Iran, Iraq, Palestine, Nigeria, Bangladesh, Libya, Ethiopia, Egypt, Syria, etc so backward, violence-prone, oppressive, regressive , devoid of human values, lack of democracy or human rights? Surely these are countries with Muslims, not kafirs?"
"Muslims always are good at pointing fingers at others for all their failures and backwardness, and they are good at only one thing: lying through their teeth unabashedly! You have this so-called; Peace TV, founded by one moron Zakir Naik who drums away tirelessly that "Islam is the solution for all Humanity". That's a big lie. These people are far from solving their own problems but blaming the 'kaffirs' for all their ills, backwardness and ignorance that they have the temerity and arrogance to talk about "solutions for all Humanity." If Islam is eradicated most of the problems of this world will automatically be solved and peace and sanity will be achieved," he added.
Reader may recall that I have discussed the topic quite elaborately in an earlier article "Muslims: Shackled People Enslaved by the Koran (http://islam-watch.org/Brahmachari/Muslims-Enslaved-by-Koran-Islam.htm). In that article, I have also pointed out that to obtain a plausible reply to these questions a study by a committee of consisting of Arab intellectuals and scholars was appointed by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) in 2001, and the committee, led by Egyptian scholar Nader Fergani, carried out a year-long investigation and thorough analysis of the reasons of backwardness of the Arab world. The findings of the study, entitled "Arab Human Development Report 2002", was published in the first week of July, 2002. Most of the authors concluded that, Islam was the ultimate culprit.
To estimate the performance of a country, the UN, for the past 10 or so years, is using the 'Human Development Index' (HDI) that includes life expectancy at birth, adult literacy rate, school enrolment as well as per capita income. Another index called 'Alternative Human Development Index' (AHDI) is also used that drops the per capita income from HDI, but includes additional factors like freedom of speech and similar fundamental rights enjoyed by the people, use of Internet, emissions of carbon dioxide and so on. In both indices, the Arab countries scored lower than almost all other countries in the world. Most of the authors of the said report commented that lack of personal freedom, freedom of speech, suppression of women were the major causes of the backwardness of the Muslims. In a nutshell, pervasive Islamization of the society has played havoc and is entirely responsible for stifling constructive Arab thought and progress. Though the above study was restricted within the Arab World, its conclusions are applicable to the Muslim community throughout the entire globe.
There are two main reasons that make the Muslims backward. Firstly, the Muslim community is being guided by the social laws ordained by Allah, through the Koran, nearly 1400 years ago. Meanwhile, the human society has immensely advanced during that period, but the Muslims discard all these advancements because all these advancements are based on laws, which are not divine but created by human beings, and hence inferior and unacceptable. So, it can be said that, though the Muslims are physically living in this modern world, mentally they are living in a world that existed 1400 years ago.
Secondly, the Koranic law that guided the Muslims, cannot be up dated. According to the Kalema Tamjid, the fourth Kalema of Islam, Muhammad was the foremost of all the Prophets Allah has so far sent to educate the people of this planet and, at the same time, he was the ultimate Prophet. It is not difficult to comprehend that, even if Allah wants to amend His laws, once He had ordained through the Koran, He will not be able to accomplish His mission for want of Prophets. This aspect of the Islamic doctrine invariably exposes that its God or Allah is horribly running short of wisdom and common sense. Even the kafirs preserve the right to up date their laws through amendment of their Constitutions, but Allah failed to foresee that such amendments of the Koranic laws might be necessary in future. Therefore, it is needless to say that Allah exposed His unlimited idiocy by His decision of not sending Prophets after Muhammad.
The Muslims of India are not outside the domain of Allah and His Koran. So it is natural that they would also be similar victims of Islamic backwardness. The Sachar Committee Report has unveiled the sad story of extreme backwardness among the Muslims of India.
The Indian Scenario:
After the present United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Government, under the leadership of the Indian National Congress Party, came into power, the Prime Minister Mr Manmohan Singh appointed a high level committee on March 9, 2005, under the chairmanship of retired Supreme Court Judge Justice Rajinder Sachar, for preparation of a report on the social, economic and educational status of the Muslim community of India. The committee, commonly called the Sachar Committee, was comprised of seven members including four Muslims. Headed by Justice Rajinder Sachar, the other members were: Sayyid Hamid, Dr.T.K. Ooman, M.A. Basith, Dr.Akhtar Majeed, Dr.Abu Saleh Shariff and Dr.Rakesh Basant. Dr.Syed Zafar Mahmood was the civil servant appointed by the PM as Officer on Special Duty to the Committee.
The committee prepared a 403-page report that was tabled in Parliament on 30 November 2006 - 20 months after obtaining the terms of reference from the PMO. It has come-up with this report with suggestions and solutions to include and mainstream Indian Muslims. It is the first of its kind report and it suggests adoption of suitable mechanisms to ensure equity and equality of opportunity to Muslims in residential, work and educational spaces. According to Sachar Committee Report the status of Indian Muslims are below the conditions of Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Quite a lot of discussions and debates are going on the Sachar Committee Report.. Follow-up actions are also being taken based on the recommendations of the Committee. P. Chidambaram, the then Finance Minister has launched a program for funding the Muslims under the name of National Minorities Development and Finance Corporation (NMDFC). Demographic Pattern of India's Muslims:According to an estimate by the UN in 2008, nearly1627.61 million Muslims live in this planet. At the beginning of the twentieth century, the Muslim population in the undivided India was close to 30 million and grew rather slowly up to 1921 and later moderately, as did the overall population. Partition led to large-scale migration, and in 1961, well after the major Partition-linked migration had ended, India's
Muslim population was enumerated at 47 million, about 10% of the total population of 439 million. The latest census, conducted in 2001, enumerated 138 million Muslims out of India's total population of 1029 million. And, many believe, by 2006 it might have crossed 150 million. This amounts to an increase of 194%, just short of trebling, and much higher than the average increase of 134%. The Muslim population growth has been close to 30% in each of the four intercensal decades since 1961, with the latest decade showing a fall to a level just below 30%. According to the Census Reports of 1981 and 1991, Muslim population, during 1991-2001 and 1981-1991, had increased by 21.5% and 23.9% respectively. While, for the majority Hindus, the population registered a fall from 32.9% to 29.5% during 1981 and 1991, and 22.7% to 19.9% during 1991 and 2001. Thus the annual growth rate of the Muslims has averaged 2.7% over the period 1961-2001, well above the national average of 2.1%. Hindus and Christians show marginally lower growth, 2.0 percent, Jains even lower, 1.8 percent, and Sikhs and Buddhists, marginally higher, 2.2 percent. So, according to the census report of 2001, Islam is India's largest minority religion, with Muslims officially constituting 13.4% of the country's population. However, unofficial estimates claim a far higher figure supposedly discounted in censuses. For instance, in an interview with a well circulated news paper of India The Hindu, Justice K.M. Yusuf, a retired Judge from Calcutta High Court and Chairman of West Bengal Minority Commission, has said that the real percentage of Muslims in India is at least 20%. The largest concentrations-about 47% of all Muslims in India, according to the 2001 census--live in the 3 states of Uttar Pradesh (30.7 million,18.5%), West Bengal (20.2 million, 25%), and Bihar (13.7 million,16.5%). Muslims represent a majority of the local population only in Jammu and Kashmir (67% in 2001) and Lakshadweep (95%). High concentrations of Muslims are found in the eastern states of Assam (31%) and West Bengal (25%), and in the southern states of Kerala (24.7%) and Karnataka (12.2%). Muslims are generally more educated, urban, integrated and prosperous in the Western and Southern states of India than in the Northern and Eastern ones; and experts believe that this could be due to partition, when the more affluent and educated population migrated over the border, to Pakistan in the North and Bangladesh (then East Pakistan) in the East. India has the third largest Muslim population (after Indonesia and Pakistan) and also the second largest Shia Muslim population (after Iran) in the world.Variation of Muslims across the Districts
Large variations were seen in the size of the Muslim population among districts. In 25 districts, the Muslim population exceeded one million each in the 2001 census. The largest was Murshidabad (3.7 million) followed by Malappuram, South Twenty-Four Paraganas, and North Twenty-Four Paraganas. Of the million plus Muslim population districts, ten are in West Bengal, five in Uttar Pradesh, three in Jammu and Kashmir, and seven in other states. Besides, in 51 districts the Muslim population is between half to one million. Thus, 76 districts have at least half a million Muslims each and just over half of India's Muslim population, 71 million out of 138 million, resides in one of these districts. At the other end, there are 106 districts with very small Muslim populations of below 10,000. Of the 593 districts of India in 2001, only 9 could be considered predominantly Muslim, that is, with an over 75% Muslim population; these included Lakshadweep and eight districts from Jammu and Kashmir. In addition, Muslims constituted 50 to 75% of the population in 11 districts (six from Assam, two from Jammu and Kashmir, and one each from Kerala, Bihar, and West Bengal).Thus, only 20 districts had a Muslim majority. About 13% of India's Muslims (just over 18 million) resided in these districts. Thirty-eight districts had a substantial, though not majority, Muslim population of over 25% but below 50%. These were distributed in a number of states, Uttar Pradesh (12), West Bengal (5), Kerala (5), Assam (4), Bihar (3), Jharkhand (2), Delhi (2), and one each in Andhra Pradesh, Haryana, Jammu and Kashmir, Uttaranchal, and Pondicherry; they accounted for 22% of India's Muslim population. In a large number of districts (182) the Muslim share was between 10 and 25%, not large but not insignificant either; these districts accounted for almost half of India's Muslim population (65 million out of 138 million, that is, 47%). At the other end, 77 districts had a very small Muslim share, less than 1%. (To be continued)
This sachar fellow must be
This sachar fellow must be the product of rape of his mother by a beggar moslem.The Pm woman singh is worst PM we have had.The genuflexing in front of moslem termites is only going to worsen the situation will worsen and termites will not stop eating the tree till the tree is brought down.
The hindus have moslms, christians and psedo secular scum bag hindus to fight against.the west is with this lot and an average hindu is not only ashamed of butalso scared of showing his hindu identity, lest he be ciminalised as a communal hindu
Hi "proudkafir" Can you tell
Hi "proudkafir" Can you tell us who is a Hindu? Before talking about "hindu identity,". First of all your so called Hinduism is not, never a belief system unlike Islam and Christianity.
Secondly your Hinduism is more Individualistic and never a group, has nothing to do with Mob mentality hence nothing to do with politics.
Your Hinduism is all about individual enlightenment, has nothing to do with fear of Hell or greed of Heaven , unlike belief systems like Christianity and Islam.
Last but the least , you can never find the word called " Hindu " in Sanskrit language. The invading Muslim pigs after crossing Sindu river started calling the land Hindustan ( in Sanskrit Bharat) .
The root of your Hinduism lies too deep even for the Islamic/Christian Termites to uproot or eat . Don't worry Time( Sanskrit Kala) the most powerful medicine is the only cure for the diseases like Islam and Christianity.
Have a nice time.Ha Ha Ha Ha
#2 Christendom not
#2
Christendom not Christianity. True Christians dont bother anyone. If you dont want the gospel true Christians move on. Muslims and christendom do otherwise!
Indian society has problems of its own. Indian men are taking the money paid in dowries and skipping India to live in West and leaving poor Indian girls alone.
The Indian women are fighting back and I say good for you. Muslim women need to do the same thing. Allah said he made Muslim women STUPID Tabari 1:280 so they are unable to rise.
Indian society has problems
I have already indictaed
I have already indictaed elsewhere the origin of the word Hindu.The persians called all those people living on the eastern bank of river sindhu as hindus as the sound Sa does not exist in persian language and they replace the sound sa with ha.Hence sindhu becomes Hindu and sapta( week) becomes hafta etc.This word hindu is a geographical term and not a religious connotation.The present papiland porkis are also hindus! as they reside on the eastern banks of the river hindu!
The better term for the spiritual and religious thoughts these people followed can be called sanatana dharma rather than Hinduism.We do not have one book( 1400 or 2000 years old) and we dont have on e prophet (one of them a pedophile rapist and the other a dead jew on a stick).
We have an evolving thought. Indian society has problems of it's own.Which idiot says there are no problems? Any society has problems.If any one thinks that either a British or An american society has no problems, he is hallucinating and is a lunatic who needs urgent admission.The islamic sociey has problems due to qrand besides the problem due to rapid awareness and spread of knowledge.The American scoiety has problems due to greed and not necessarily due to bible as many have found out the uselessness of the bible.
Indian society has problems inspite of the rich instructions available in Gita purely due to ignorance of the population. Hope I have clarified my thoughts.Moslems termites have a problem every where due to their absolute stupidity and allhameralauda's ignorance.
Sachar committee did not
Sachar committee did not address the no of criminals in muslim society.Rapists, gang leaders, goons,supari killers,mafia members,examination question paper leak out mafia,etc. Also the %of muslim criminals to their population should have been calculated vis Hindu criminals to hindu population . Also it did not address the wealth of muslim leaders,mullahs & jerks like naik.It would be interesting.
The negative growth of Hindu population is more then mentioned.I am sure.BUT THE NEGATIVE GROWTH OF CHRISTIAN POPULATION IS NOT A GROUND REALITY.MARK MY WORDS,FUTURE CENSUS WILL SHOW A SUDDEN SPURT IN GROWTH OF THEIR POPULATION.THE NEO CONVERTS ARE STILL LOOSELY HINDUS,(to get govt benefits)BUT WITH CHRISTIAN BELIEFS.THE 2 OR 3rd GENERATION WILL OFFICIALLY DECLARE THEMSELVES AS CHRISTIANS.
Raisin head,are you a member of the siddi tribe?????
Muslims have never invented
Muslims have never invented anything. Algebra was stolen from the Indians when Muslims invaded India and killed 80 million Indians who welcomed Muslims , only to be stabbed in the back. If Muslims had an ounce of sense, they would know they did nothing. When Muhammad went to Paradise on the back of the horse named buraq with a woman's head, that came from Greek myths. Only after an invasion of another country were muslims ever given credit for any invention. The dumbest of all are the African Muslims who are slaves of Arabs and they except this degradation willingly. Indians know what Muslims have done and are still doing and say nothing, but still are appeasing.
I dont care how nice one treats muslims, you will be stabbed in the back, and the front if you allow it. Educated Muslims, although nonsensical, are to be held accountable for not informing the peons of their world. The fact that Muslims have to leave their world to be free proves that Islam is evil. Americans are sick and tired of the Race card muslims try to deal. Is Islam a RACE or political faction. Look at the UK. Hindus are finally fighting back. Africans are fighting back. The world of infidels are fighting back. DO UNTO MUSLIMS BEFORE THEY DO UNTO YOU-INFIDEL 1:1
Raisin Head, you did not
Raisin Head, you did not answer my question.Are you a member of the siddi tribe????
#4 There was a movie news
#4 There was a movie news flash from India in America today. The one man they caught returned the 10,000 to the woman. They have many, many more men in Canada. I didnt write the info. Indian women made the film.
#8 No I am not of the Siddi tribe. If I was born in India I would be whatever my family would be. Like most black Americans, I would be lighter skinned than most Indians, as most blacks in America are mixed, with America Indians, European and tenth generation African. My husband was so light he could pass for an European 1st generation, but he chose not to pass unless we needed to. (smile). Most black Americans can tell what race a person is. We are use to it. Sometimes it pays to speak Harvard, and sometimes it pays to speak hood. (smile) Personally I like ebonics. I will leave Harvard talk to President Obama and Michele.
Apparently he didnt read much of Islam, as he married a dark skinned woman, and in Islam that is a curse. Hadith 9:162,3.
Mississippi Burning showed
Mississippi Burning showed how racist some Indians were against black people. Denzel Washington was the handsome black man who dated the India woman who played his lead. Denzel is one of the highest paid movie stars in America and yet he played a part which showed a darker skinned Indian girl who was not allowed to date a black man. When will people wake up and stop this color thing. It is sickening. A man is a man and a woman is a woman. God created al of us and we have caused all of this evil, vile,crazy racism. I hope my children and your children stop and refuse to entertain this insanity. Sex is sex and I hurt having a baby like any other woman does. We have a bigger fight against Islam, a political evil that hates us all. VICTORY!
i just asked you because you
i just asked you because you were espousing the rights of africo indians.???wonder what you are talking about if you are not a member of the siddi tribe.
oh,you meant american
oh,you meant american indians?excuse me.
No problem. I enjoy a livey
No problem. I enjoy a livey debate and an exchange of thoughts. The Dalits and Siddi have suffered much in India and it is time to stop. If advance are to be made, lets start right now today, and never allow anyone to keep this race hatred going on. Are we intelligent or not. People who alow this crap to continue are arrogant and will never stop the wars in our countries. Americans are tired of the hate, when most of us are just trying to make a living. Most of us see India as a beautiful country with pretty people. Most Americans dont know how Afro Indians are/were treated. The beautiful outfits and people is all most of us know. I just happen to know East Indians personally, which makes me a little different. The Dalit Panthers are in India. Just like we had Black Panthers in the 1960-now. Most have died out. Most of them were Black Muslims and didnt like Dr. King, yet he was a christian and still helped them.
They didnt care as they were Muslims. Most Black Muslims really dont know true Islam, just Farrahkan's Islam and the Moorish Science with their own personal Quran.
The cream of the Leftist
The cream of the Leftist morons can be found in India. The Maoists, Nexalites, Muslims, and many Christian organizations work round the clock to achieve their fragile goals. The Sachar committee Report was drafted by Congress govt to appease the minority (read Muslims).
I had some time today to
I had some time today to watch the videos posted bykrishna786 and felt all moscum bags shuld be nuked.Particularly when the ugly bustard keeps repeating kuffar kufar, as if he is uttering a hateful word.The scum bag moslem spews so much hatred, I wonder why the kafirs are keeping quiet.
Its time to get rid of the moslems in my place.Out they go, if they do not reject mohammad the rapist pedophile bastard, and the pimp allahmeralauda.
Moscum bags are termites, the intestinal bacteria found in the crap.Qrand is pile of stinking sh1t of mohammamahalauda.The pedophile bastarsd has really screwed the world and ayesha.Moscums should be given option of choose death or reject the bastard mohmmadlauda and allahmeralauda.
#14 nO cHRISTIANS JOIN
#14 nO cHRISTIANS JOIN POLITICS, AS jESUS SAID HIS KINGDOM WAS NOT OF THIS WORLD. Rome's pontif, Constantine started Christendom and spread catholicism by the sword and the roman armies. Remember it is christendom, not christianity. Jesus died rather than be made king. Matt. 4.
Jesus went and hid to keep the people from making him king after he healed the sick, etc. Jews saw that he was god's son. He refused. Not one apostle was king. Paul was a high ranking Jewish Pharisee and he stopped killing Christians and started preaching the gospel.
Remember Christendom is the political one not Christians. If the NT didnt say do it, and so-called Christians do it, then you know they are not following Jesus.
Roman version of Jesus is from Satan, the real god of this world-2 Cor. 4:4 and John 8:44. Constantine was baptized on his deathbed, although he was a pagan all of his life in order to be on the good side of both. SLICK!