Printer-friendly version
Send to friend
PDF versionFrom: Marci N.
To:
faithfreedom2@gmail.com
Date: Apr 28, 2006 9:13 PM
Subject: your Web site
Dear Ali,
Thank you for the work you do to challenge Islam. I don't know much about it, but I wanted to tell you that a good friend of mine was schizophrenic, and I helped my friend closely for thirty years and so I know schizophrenia well. Based on that life experience, I have wondered for some time whether Mohammed was schizophrenic; after reading your site, I can see that I was right. The imagery that Mohammed employs is very schizophrenic. It's so interesting how similar schizophrenia manifests itself in its victims, and I believe that those similarities may be explained by the path that the excess dopamine travels in the brain. A lot of modern psychopath leaders sound a lot like untreated schizophrenics as well, as you so aptly point out on your brilliantly done Web site. I wish the world would hurry up and listen to you. You make more sense than anyone has yet on this subject. Hard for me to believe that so many people have been so taken in by someone's rantings. I guess if it's all a person has ever known, that person after a while adopts the whole framework of thought and so it all makes some sort of sense to them. It is shocking that so few people realize what is causing the imagery in the first place.
However, because not all schizophrenics are evil murderers, I have to think that the desire to hurt other people, the sadism, the sexual predation--I think those defects were there in Mohammed and Hitler and then the schizophrenia came on top of them and adds to the mental mayhem. Where O Where are the world's psychiatrists? If we could prevent the next generation from succombing to Islam, we could prevent enormous suffering.
How will we ever stop the Islamification of Western Europe?
I can't help wondering if World War III will see France, Sweden, Germany, Spain, and England asking the United States to help them get this monster off their continent. But is this the continuation really of unfinished World War II? I think it really is. Just as World War II began with World War I.
The lesson the world learned from watching the Nazis was about religion and prejudice; those lessons do not go far enough. The real lesson to have taken away from that madness was about sadism, which as Victor Frankl said, exists universally everywhere.
We have to learn how to recognize it.
Thank you for your rational work.
Marci
[color=purple]
Thank you for your encouraging words. The work has just begun and there is a long road ahead. Please do tell as many people as you can about FFI for the education of those who are taken in by the "Islam is a peaceful religion" is as important as helping the muslims work their way out of Islam. AliSina is extremely busy with his forthcoming book and with tasks related to his site. He does get to see all the emails eventually.
The islamification of europe will not take place if we are successful becuase the Islam will not be there in any meaningful strength. It is the muslims in the open environment of the west that we can reach the fastest and hopefully before Islam can take over Europe we can liberate the muslims from Islam. The task is going to be able to wake the general average european and their leaders up to the danger that confronts them.
Doubtless[/color]
Hi, I already did. I just sent this note to the editors of RealClearPolitics. I hope it gets some attention. It will probably work and you've got a long road to reach a billion people. Godspeed! and thank you for your work. You may save a great many lives. I read admire what you've done. So here's my letter (sent to
www.realclearpolitics.com):
Dear RCP:
I was just reading the excellent article you put up tonight by McCarthy, "The So-Called Religion of Peace," after I just also finished reading Daniel Henninger's WSJ piece in which he writes of an interview with George P. Shultz. All I can say is that Iran is on everyone's mind, including mine, tonight.
I was earlier reading Little Green Footballs, where one of the commenters referred readers to this Web site:
http://www.faithfreedom.org/
As the child of a schizophrenic mom (I loved her very much, and she just passed away in January, and the schizophrenia was not her wish or her doing), I've seen schizophrenia in many dimensions, and for that reason I have always wondered if Mohammed was schizophrenic. After spending a couple of hours on the Faith Freedom Web site, I am sure I was right all along, as Ali Sina documents flawlessly. Mr. Sina is an ex-Irania Muslim who is trying desperately to communicate with the Muslims interested in leaving the cult of Islam and with Westerners who need to understand this world movement if we are to protect ourselves against it. He does not mince words.
Forgive me if you've already given some type of publicity to this particular Web site, but if you haven't, and you know of some way to get it into mass circulation (Technorati perhaps? although this site is not a blog exactly), can you do so? I learned a lot, and I think others will too. It gets at a lot of the questions circulating about Islam.
I fear the future, and I wonder why the CIA (as in James Bond?) can't do something about Iran? ugh.
Thank you for the work you do. I check RCP several times a day. I am a loyal fan [and my praise means something because I'm a freelance editor! so be justly complimented. We editors are notoriously picky people! :) ]
[color=purple]
Dear Marci
I think Muhammad suffered from NPD which in severe cases can be somewhat similar to schizophrenia. He also suffered of Temporal lobe epilepsy. All the symptoms of both these ailments were stated in the hadith. In the later years of his life he was affected by Acromegaly and probably he died of this disease. In childhood it is possible that he suffered from bipolar. From what I know of schizophrenia, I don't think that was what he suffered of. The evil in his heart was caused by NPD.
If you like I can send you the manuscript of my first book. In this book I have talked only of his narcissistic personality disorder. In my second book From Mecca to 9/11 which is his biography, I have talked about all his disorders in more detail. If you like I can send you my manuscript. Since you are a freelance editor, you might have some good suggestions for me.
Also my agent is still looking for a publisher and it looks she hasn't had much luck. Maybe this genre is not what she handles usually. If you know of a publisher that you think might be interested to look at the ms, I would be very grateful if you could kindly put us in contact. I will have to honor my agent of course anyway.
Wish you the best
Ali Sina [/color]
Hi Mr. Sina,
Thank you for responding to my e-mail. I've written some replies to your notes in between the lines below.
[color=purple]
Dear Marci
I think Muhammad suffered from NPD which in severe cases can be somewhat similar to schizophrenia. He also suffered of Temporal lobe epilepsy. All the symptoms of both these ailments were stated in the hadith. In the later years of his life he was affected by Acromegaly and probably he died of this disease. In childhood it is possible that he suffered from bipolar. From what I know of schizophrenia, I don't think that was what he suffered of. The evil in his heart was caused by NPD.[/color]
His fixation on the human body and his taking bits from the existing Bible and embellishing them way out of proportion were what caused me to wonder if he was schizophrenic. Those are both commonly seen in schizophrenics. The NPD research you have done is far more imformative than schizophrenia and I'm sure your correct in that diagnosis. I just happened to know a little bit about hallucinations caused by schizophrenia, and I felt that Mohammed might have been that. I'm sure you're right-- I don't know much about NPD except that I think I read that Hitler had this disorder. And the diagnosis of manic-depressive in a fairly new one to me as I've been involved with the pschiatric field for thirty years. I'm sure you're right about all of this and that NPD can end up on hallucinations as well. The common denominator here might be the isolation leading to madness and hallucinations and delusions. Someone who is narcissistic is by definition totally isolated from other people, and like Saddam Hussein, Kim Il Jong (the "Dear Leader"), and Fidel Castro will eventually lose touch with reality.
[color=purple]
If you like I can send you the manuscript of my first book. In this book I have talked only of his narcissistic personality disorder. In my second book From Mecca to 9/11 which is his biography, I have talked about all his disorders in more detail. If you like I can send you my manuscript. Since you are a freelance editor, you might have some good suggestions for me.[/color]
Thank you for considering sending me your manuscript. I am honored. But I will not have time to look at it for a while as I am involved in another time-consuming project. I will write again when I am free to see if you are still able to send it to me. I just can't do that right now. But I thank you for the opportunity.
[color=purple]
Also my agent is still looking for a publisher and it looks she hasn't had much luck. Maybe this genre is not what she handles usually. If you know of a publisher that you think might be interested to look at the ms, I would be very grateful if you could kindly put us in contact. I will have to honor my agent of course anyway.[/color]
I also wish you would send it to some of the television stations. You have written a thoughtful analysis of Mohammed's likely condition, and we live in an era of forensic psychological evaluations of historical figures. So this would be a back door to the left-wing people who are in denial about Islam and who want to legitimize Islam as a religion not because they know anything about it but because it makes them feel smart and liberal to be open to Islam. Clearly they know nothing about it. But perhaps we can educate them without their knowing it by supplying them this information about his mental disorder.
That said, I imagine this puts you at risk from the terrorists. Michele Malkin was at risk just for publishing the Danish cartoons. I'm amazed how Internet savvy the terrorists are.
So be careful. Especially since you are the one with the key to understanding this "religion." I hope you have some contacts within the U.S. military intelligence community. They need this understanding.
The American soldiers who have been stationed in Iraq that I know of always say the same thing, that they are appalled at how brainwashed the Islamic population is and how desperately they need religious freedom.
So hang in there and persist. Your work will save hundreds or thousands of people.
You shine a lone candle in the darkness.
Marci