A Letter from an Ex-Muslim

Ali Sina

Ali Sina is the author of Understanding Muhammad and Muslims.

9 Responses

  1. Richard says:

    “Of course Terry can speak for himself, but Catholic dogma is ALWAYS about faith/morals and NOT about politics. ”
    Catholic dogma maybe – but ROMAN Catholic dogma has always been distinguished by the position of the pope.

    Discard that and what are you left with? the Orthodox Church

  2. Face_The_Truth says:

    “Jesus founded one Church,…”



  3. A.H. says:

    Ali wrote:
    “@Terry Gain, You are a Catholic because you believe in the Catholic dogmas, the most important of them being papal infallibility.”

    Of course Terry can speak for himself, but Catholic dogma is ALWAYS about faith/morals and NOT about politics. I think that your understanding of dogmas has to do with your Muslim upbringing, probably because in Islamic dogma God and Caesar (Shah if you will) are intertwined.Though you have a Muslim upbringing you sound also as a Protest-ant.

    To take away your misconceptions about the Church, I invite you to read the Catechism thoroughly, you only will find the constant teaching of the Church about faith/morals over almost 2000 years, it is not about politics.

    And yes, popes failed in their politics, it started already with Peter in Acts 15, and throughout the history of the Church there are plenty of ugly examples. It was, I think, C.K. Chesterton who said that the Church is a place of saints and sinners.

    Jesus founded one Church, and he promised to keep her in all truth (in faith and morals) and that even the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. Yes, the Church will fail in her politics but cannot fail in her faith and morals. This is what the Catholic Church believes.

    Once again the politics of popes are no dogmas, so Terry can think what he wants in this case aboute the Pope and follow his own conscience and yet be a good Catholic.

  4. Ali Sina says:

    @Terry Gain, You are a Catholic because you believe in the Catholic dogmas, the most important of them being papal infallibility. Yet you are calling Pope Francis a fool. How do you reconcile your assertion with your faith? Note that the Vatican history is filled with popes who0 were less than honorable and outright pervert and criminals. You have to make your mind. You either believe in the Catholic dogmas or you are not a Catholic.

  5. Terry Gain says:

    Ali Sina
    As a non-Muslim I find you a great resource to learn about the evil ideology called Islam. As a Catholic I am however upset with what you say about my church. I have no use for the current Pope who is a fool for Islam but the Vatican is not satanic and you discredit yourself by claiming that it is.

  6. A.H. says:

    Ali wrote:

    “I am only sharing my honest point of view. My suggestion is become a member of a protestant Church”

    There is not such a thing as protestant Church, Protestantism is a collection of thousands of denominations with all sorts of different theologies.

    In Mat. 16,18 Jesus founded a (one) Church, and authorized his disciples to teach all things whatsoever he had commanded. This Church does still exist until this very day, to teach all things whatsoever he had commanded, it is the Church of the ages. He did not command his disciples to examine NDEs, but he called those blessed who have not seen and yet have believed.

  7. Richard says:

    RE – the suggestion to join the protestant church vs the Roman Catholics. Well there is another option – the Orthodox church. Many protestant churches have actually been fooled by Islamic apologists – especially in places like Sweden.

    You can find out about Orthodoxy on this site: https://facingislam.blogspot.co.uk/

    Many ex-muslims have found a good home in the Orthodox Church – for example Fr Daniel Byantoro http://orthochristian.com/80185.html

    and btw the liturgy is beautiful https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ukt7DXWr60

  8. Face_The_Truth says:

    Ali Muhammad Amir Abd’Allah Umar Salehi ibn Sina writes, “The sharia requires her to wear hijab.”

    In fact, in New York City, Islamic Shariat (i.e., Islamic jurisprudence) is protected over local laws as faithful Muslim-American females are receiving financial compensation(s) for any alleged or real violation of Islamic Shariat as the following LINK shows.


  9. Pankaj Saraswat says:

    Very good brother that you have finally left shaitanislam.It is the biggest danger for civilized world and humanity.Even i am an exmuslim and I got this that quran is book of shaitan and Mohammad was actually a shaitan and child rapist and sexually perverted man.For inciting bloodshed and his sexual manias he developed whole set of hate ideologies which is that sixth century barbaric filth islam.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: