WILL REMOVE THIS SITE IF PROVEN WRONG

 Home

 Articles

 Op-ed

 Authors

 FAQ

 Leaving Islam
 Library
 Gallery
 Comments
 Debates
  Links
 Forum

 

  Arabic

عربي

  Chinese
  Czech
  Dutch Forum
  Français
  German
  Indonesian
  Iran Page
  Italian
  Polish Forum
  Spanish Forum

 

 

Dear Dr Ali Sina,  

I was reading your article and you threw a challenge by saying “Show me one Islamic country that is prosperous and its people are free and happy or its jails are not filled with dissidents.” I was wondering if Malaysia fits the bill. What do you think?  

BT

Islam means submission, which is synonymous to subjection and subjugation and antonymous to freedom. There is no freedom and liberty in any Islamic country. When they say Malaysia is a moderate Islamic country, it is in comparison to other Islamic countries that are brutal and oppressive. It does not mean that human rights in that country are respected or in anyway Malaysia is comparable to a truly democratic and secular country like India, for example. The following news clarifies the point. 

 

Muslim burial for Malaysian hero

Kaliammal Sinnasamy (left), the widow of M. Moorthy
Mr Moorthy's widow was in tears after Wednesday's ruling
BBC Bews

2005/12/29

A Malaysian mountaineering hero will be buried as a Muslim, against the wishes of his Hindu wife, who denied he had converted to Islam before his death.

The decision follows a High Court ruling that it cannot override the country's Islamic courts in matters of religious conversion.

An Islamic court had said the man, M Moorthy, had become a Muslim last year.

Lawyers say the case highlights problems faced by non-Muslims dealing with Malaysia's Islamic justice system.

"So much for good interracial relations," Haris Mohamad Ibrahim, a lawyer representing Malaysia's Bar Council, told The Associated Press.

"The judge has just told the widow and her family to go back and leave the body of their beloved to be buried by strangers."

Coma

M Moorthy, 36, was a Hindu when he became a national hero in 1997 as a member of the first Malaysian expedition to conquer Mount Everest.

But when he died a week ago family supporters and state Islamic officials jostled one another at the mortuary as each tried to claim his body.

An Islamic Sharia court subsequently upheld a claim by his former colleagues in the army that he had become a Muslim last year.

However his family, who want him to have a Hindu funeral, were not allowed to appear before the court to dispute his conversion because they are not Muslims.

The family went to the civil court and argued that Mr Moorthy was a practising Hindu right up to a recent accident when he fell from his wheelchair and lapsed into a coma.

They say he was even interviewed for local television two months ago about his preparations for the Hindu festival of Diwali.

But the High Court agreed with government lawyers who argued the civil court had no jurisdiction.

Lawyers for the dead man's relatives say the ruling leaves non-Muslims little protection in family disputes considered under Islamic law.

Most Malaysians are Muslim but the country's constitution guarantees freedom of worship for all.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home     Articles     Op-ed     Authors      FAQ     Leaving Islam     Debates     Library     Gallery     Comments        Links              Forum

 

 

  ©  copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.