Russian Miracle Baby or Skin Disease?
Allegedly, the words appear on the child’s arms, legs and stomach of the nine month old Ali – before fading away and being replaced with new verses.
Ali’s parents say that they were not religious until the writings started appearing on his skin, which is verified by their doctor and the imam in their village of Red October, a strongly Muslim region.
‘Ali always feels bad when it is happening. He cries and his temperature goes up. It’s impossible to hold him when it’s happening, his body is actively moving, so we put him into his cradle. It’s so hard to watch him suffering. The phrases regularly replace each other on the baby’s skin,‘ she said.
He said that one sign read: ‘Don’t hide these signs from the people.’
The story has attracted considerable attention from not just the Muslim media but it has been reported even by Ruiters India and ABC News.
According to one report (Kizlyar, Russia) – “Up to two-thousand Muslims from the northern region of Russia are daily making the pilgrimage to the small Russian town of Kizlyar to see nine-month-old Ali Yakubov.”
According to Wikipedia the symptoms are thought to be caused by mast cells in the surface of the skin releasing histamines without the presence of antigens, due to the presence of a weak membrane surrounding the mast cells. The histamines released cause the skin to swell in the affected areas.
This weak membrane easily and rapidly breaks down under physical pressure causing an allergic-like reaction, generally a red wheal(welt) to appear on the skin. It can often be confused with an allergic reaction to the object causing a scratch, when in fact it is the act of being scratched that causes a wheal to appear. These wheals are a subset of urticaria (hives) that appear within minutes, accompanied by a sensation of burning, and itchiness. The first outbreak of urticaria can lead to others on body parts not directly stimulated, scraped or scratched. In a normal case the swelling will reduce itself with no treatment within 15–30 minutes, but in extreme cases, itchy red wheals may last anywhere from a few hours to days.
As it turns out this alleged miracle that has caused so much uproar is just a skin disease. The writings are made by a selfish mother who torments her child to garner attention. In a civilized society this woman would be charged with child abuse and her baby taken away from her. But in an Islamic world, hungry for miracles she receives homage.
Why a loving God would torture a baby in such a way and what does he want to prove? Let us say someone came in the middle of the night and did this to your baby, would you say this person is a good person? Assuming these writings are paranormal, it is child abuse and quite diabolic.
Isn’t there a better way for Allah to prove that he is real than torturing a baby? Wouldn’t it be easier and more logical to give enough knowledge to Muslims so they can answer the critics of his religion and shut their mouths and their sites with irrefutable logic? Why torment a defenseless innocent baby? There is no logical proof for Islam. However, fake miracles abound.
This is another case revealing the pathetic state of the Muslim mind.
People here who talk bad about Islam, think before you cowards talk. You do not know anything about Islam. Go and read the Quran, don’t just open your dirty mouths with rubbish. I believe in God. And I believe in Miracles, Whether he shows it through a Muslim, Christian or Jew. We all believe in the same God so it is the one god that is sending the message. We are all his people. whether you are a jew, christian, or muslim or whatever. Whether this headline about the baby is true or not, I do not know becuase i haven’t read all about it, but that doesn’t give you the right to put Islam down. There are good and bad people in all religions…why don’t you guys talk about your perverted priests that sexually abbuse children? No, of coarse you don’t, the truth is, they are not believers of God, for the good and pious priests that truly beleive in God, would never do such a thing.
I am not saying that all christian people are bad, or that only muslim people are good, but what I am trying to say is that there are good and bad people everywhere and sometimes they make the religion they are in look bad. Don’t judge Islam, Christianity or Judaism, just by meeting a Muslim/Christian/Jew, or by what you hear about them, try to learn about it through the source…read their book. READ THE BOOK. and I know 100% you people have not read the Quran, becuase if you have, you would not talk like this. I am a muslim, and I am very proud to be a muslim. Islam is a peaceful religion. and don’t ever confuse religion with Culture, some of the muslims, you guys hear about that do weird things, they are not following religion, but following their culture that they have followed for thousands of years.
My point again, is that you should not judge a religion based on meeting some messed up person who clams to be from that religion. try to learn about it and then make a judgement.
All god is asking from us, is to be good people and to treat each other kindly. Islam is a peaceful Religion. IF you read the holy books, you will notice how similar these three books are.
I feel very sorry for those who do not believe in God or in the hearafter.
God gives us a miracle everyday. You just need to look for them.
you morons… you are fooling yourslef.. no matter how many times you say its a skin diseases..
your devlish mind would never be able to bring logic why this skin diseases always result in quranic verses rather then free masonry symbols? !
and if you are all trying to blame mother that shes doing all that.. then you idiotic morons ..
not a single 1 of you.. suggested to prove it by monitoring child nonstop for 24 hours and to see if this is work of his mother or its from GOD !
idiots !
you morons… you are fooling yourslef.. no matter how many times you say its a skin diseases..
your devlish mind would never be able to bring logic why this skin diseases always result in quranic verses rather then free masonry symbols? !
and if you are all trying to blame mother that shes doing all that.. then you idiotic morons ..
not a single 1 of you.. suggested to prove it by monitoring child nonstop for 24 hours and to see if this is work of his mother or its from GOD !
idiots !
Hey, this site is missing many comments! Where are they? My curiosities haven’t been answered yet.
“I see people here wondering how would the merciful God torture a baby if this is a miracle. I really can’t imagine how pitiful it is when a human compares himself with the God. Please grow up little thinkers, are you coming here to interrogate how God should be like or should do!! Who are you to do that ?? Have you forgotten that you were created from a drop of dirty sperm ??!!”
The facts that this “miracle” is odd and forgery are overwhelming. Just look at the fevers, it weren’t necessary at all. Miracles defy natural order, so it should be without fevers at all. Second, this miracle is pretty much useless and have a “show-off” characteristic. Third, i never see this “miracle” on the news in my own country (indonesia)! Why? Humans are from one single cell sperm (competed with another cells) and a woman’s cell egg, not a drop of “dirty sperm”. Get it right will ya, your god seems clueless on this. So, this life is all competition and survival from the very start you were born. The survival of the fittest.
“Yes we do know that God is the most gracious, the merciful, but God is the most knowledgeable in existence to show his miracle the way he orders based on that knowledge, you can never know the real wisdom behind his acts whoever you are or how much knowledge you think you obtain in your short life. Stop your materialism thinking. You really only show your limitless stupidity when you argue an act of God. Only God knows his wisdom behind any of his acts. And how do you even know that the baby was tortured, is it because you saw him crying. Again you referred to human reasoning, you are not inside the baby to feel what is happening or feeling even if he is crying. God takes care of him in his way. Again it is a God act that you cannot argue or explain.”
Your logic are simply confusing. You said that God is the most bla..bla..bla. Do you even understand the word the “most”? Your sentence is just your pure assumption. when you mention the most merciful or gracious that means this “God” is in the no. 1 ranking of mercy and grace exceeding all humans/angels/whatever you can think of including the passionate Buddha. So, if even mere humans can pity with this baby, so should God, but this “God” didn’t. The baby was indeed suffering, not just crying, look at this article fully. Wrong, you assume that God can do this and that without any single proof at all, so if allah lied about heaven and hell or virgins, etc, he can (that’s the whole point isn’t? no rule or moral standard can bind him, beside you can’t understand him or argue with him so you can’t protest). The worse part is that you consider it as allah the barbarian god from 7th century. A good and reasonable god would act according to human’s standard to avoid confusion. When you want to talk to a kid, you use kid’s language and tone, not scientist’s language, they won’t understand it. Who is at fault here, you or the kid? Do you want to have unreasonable confusing leader or president? No, is the correct answer because it will create chaos.
“I am Muslim and in conclusion i would say when the true believers in God see this miracle or other miracles, they don’t boost or raise the level of their believe in God any more, but these miracles are intended only for other non-believers to introduce them to God, and most probable they will come with endless justifications as they did here as we see when they referred this miracle as a disease precisely as their ancestors did in the past to deny such miracles and facts about God because they really do know what this means and what it makes if they don’t influence people around them to deny it. They get jealous because they live with a false religion that made of nothing but claims and has nothing to offer or prove to them about the real God and purpose of life.”
No need to say it. I already know your are muslim from the very start because you didn’t even care about the baby or the logic of this miracle. Pure belief and wishful thinking again. Your islamic miracles are/were very vague, check my response to Asian girl. I have seen a lot of “miracles” in my own country and most of them involving other beliefs other than islam and better yet the tv reported it, unlike this miracle. you can say that i’ve got used to see “miracle”
“Even if they see angels coming down from the sky, they will come up with excuses and justifications to make people around them blindly deny and never believe. This miracle will not make many people believe or return to their mind, but it is just to remind them in the judgment day that God has proved to them one day that he exists so they have no excuse that time, they will only then curse themselves because of the stubborn, blocked mentality they were living with in their past lives.”
Stop right there. You have made a logical fallacy here. Angel coming down from the sky? Where? How? When? Tell me. Before you make a statement, you must mention some proof of the angel that happened before to make your statement valid. Wait, i don’t understand here, blocked mentality? according to your belief, it was allah who blocked them in the first place, now this allah blames humans, wow. Pretty selfish god if you ask me. You are spewing your faith here without any proof just as the other myths can.
“I am not asking anyone to believe what I am saying, but if you are really concerned to know the ultimate reality and to wake you up from your coma in life , I ask you not to believe me or any Muslim here or there but only to read Quran and Sunnah yourself and you make your judgement after that, but I know many non-believers they will never do this only because they live in their stubborn mentality and they decided to live blind in this live until they wake up after they die where they will no longer have any choice to return to the right path but only remember it was your choice and no one forced you to live with.”
Sorry, man. but you just contradicted your own teaching. Islam is all about conquering this world for allah either with preaching, wars, deception (taqqiya), and terror. Look at the history not your ego. Look at sectarian wars. Look at minorities (people of the book and other religions).
For all those who attacking Islam, have you forgotten what this is about? Why did an article about a this boy turn into a hate campaign against muslims? I understand how much you care for this boy and don’t want him to suffer but do you not care about the muslims you are offending? Those ordinary muslims who live thier lives following the true message of islam and not the radical views of the extremists associated with the religion? I understand that this is something controversial which is why you are desperately looking for a scientific answer. But what if this scientific idea you have found has been provided by Allah s.w.t.? What if i told you that science and islam work together rather than contridicting each other? I am not an expert in the Qu’ran but i know that the Qu’ran has detailed descriptions of conception and foetuses even though it was written in a time when none of this was known to mankind. How could Muhammad (P.B.U.H) known all of this? He could not even read or write! And for those who say Islam is a religion of hate then i can assure you your wrong! Islam means “to achieve PEACE by submitting your will to Allah s.w.t”. How can this religion be a religion of violence and hate? Those who use Islam to bakc up thier radical views are nothing but extremists who are not muslims! Islam does not hate or mock any other religion! When muslims speak of Jesus (P.B.UH) or Moses (P.B.U.H) they always follow it with the phrase Peace Be Upon Him so we do not disrespect any other religion or their views. Also for those who believe that Islam opresses women, i suggest they read the Qu’ran and make an effort to understand it. Becuase if you did you would realise that it promotes gender equality even though it was written in a time when women were thought of as much lower than men. Why are women covering therselves thought of as being oppressed? Surely women who feel they have to wear tight clothes and show off their bodies are being oppressed? Aren’t women being raped and molested being oppressed? i’m sorry you are not ready to accept the beauty of islam into your heart but i hope you understand that all the bad association with islam are more to do with the people than the religion itself!
Hi Moooo, All the enjoyment of commenting has lost, I have to search out the friends where they are commenting. Yes, the change in website has given a golden chance to LondonSpirit for escape and he has escaped. Why dont u start your blog, all the friends will join you there.
“For all those who attacking Islam, have you forgotten what this is about? Why did an article about a this boy turn into a hate campaign against muslims?”
This site is all about islam and this section is all about revealing the “fake” science of islam. Read the context.
“I understand how much you care for this boy and don’t want him to suffer but do you not care about the muslims you are offending?”
The boy are indeed suffering, but muslim (who insult and curse other faiths – fact, don’t bother to refute it, caused i see it) are only suffering in their ego (which is useless).
“Those ordinary muslims who live thier lives following the true message of islam and not the radical views of the extremists associated with the religion?”
What do you mean by “ordinary”? I only see sectarian and hypocrite muslims.
“I understand that this is something controversial which is why you are desperately looking for a scientific answer.”
There are no answer for this, never will. I’m waiting for international news for islamic science, none come to me. In fact, even in my country (muslim majority without sharia) this kind of sciences never exist in the news. Islamic science enter my mind AFTER i read islamic websites. Ring a bell?
“What if i told you that science and islam work together rather than contridicting each other?”
Nothing would happen. Because they don’t work together. Read this site article and forum, especially the science section.
“How could Muhammad (P.B.U.H) known all of this? He could not even read or write!”
Read the article regarding that.
“And for those who say Islam is a religion of hate then i can assure you your wrong! Islam means “to achieve PEACE by submitting your will to Allah s.w.t”. How can this religion be a religion of violence and hate? ”
Your assurance doesn’t look reliable to me. Islam primary meaning is submission to allah, then peace means islamic peace. Yes, it can be violence and hate, don’t you see the reality (from 7th until now)?
“Islam does not hate or mock any other religion! When muslims speak of Jesus (P.B.UH) or Moses (P.B.U.H) they always follow it with the phrase Peace Be Upon Him so we do not disrespect any other religion or their views”
Google it first before vomitting lies. You muslim only consider Christians and Jews as 2nd class citizens. What about Buddha, Hindu saints, Confucious, Tao, Bahai, Ahmadi, etc? Do you respect them? No, you mock them. I have seen it myself, so lying is useless to me.
“Also for those who believe that Islam opresses women, i suggest they read the Qu’ran and make an effort to understand it. Becuase if you did you would realise that it promotes gender equality even though it was written in a time when women were thought of as much lower than men.”
Read? See is more powerful than read. Words can be manipulated but reality is not. Gender equality is from secular world not muslim. So, tell me where is the islamic nation (with sharia) that practices that gender bal..bla..bla? Vomitting lies again. Sigh. You could be a good politician.
“Surely women who feel they have to wear tight clothes and show off their bodies are being oppressed?”
Wrong. Woman are free to wear anything they like and get a job. There are no pressure to that. You don’t understand the word “oppress”. Living in western world make your credibility down to zero.
“Aren’t women being raped and molested being oppressed?”
In muslim countries you are deserve to be raped if you don’t wear islamic clothes. Wow. happy now? Rape in islamic countries are games for man. Check the flaw of your own law.
“i’m sorry you are not ready to accept the beauty of islam into your heart but i hope you understand that all the bad association with islam are more to do with the people than the religion itself! ”
Talking about something that doesn’t exist in the first palce is ridiculous. All muslim follow islam to its core. Just look at middle east. Religion is their motivation and sanction. I say it again: Living in western world make your credibility down to zero.
Ali Sina is getting mad! WHy don’t you go to that village and accuse the parents? Show yourself man!
Great reaction of Moooo to Asian Girl, thank you, you always say it so well, yet so concise. I always enjoy, look forward to them. Keep it up!!!
What is written in the Quran, and what Muhammad allegedly already knew is always, on thorough examination, found to be in very vague wording, just like the so-called prophecies of Nostradamus. One example of that: He mentioned a bad ruler named “Hister” and many explained that name as “Hitler”.
These interpretations of prophecies and Quran are soooooo artificial and contrived. Muslims at times are sooooo gullible, naive. But only in respect to their religion, in many other respects they can be very smart and I think they are getting smarter all the time, due to progress in education, communication, internet, English language.
But according to Lee Harris as I understand him, in his book “The suicide of Reason. Radical Islam’s threat to the West” most or many Muslims, in relation to other religion-believers or atheists, are primarily loyal to their tribe, Islam.
It is a feast for rational thinkers when again and again Muslims are shown good logic, given good rational answers by Ali Sina and his crew, his allies and many, many visitors to their websites, like Moooo. And yet, loyalty to their tribe Islam, so often, makes them resort to widespread Islamic propaganda, already countless times refuted arguments, so often so illogical, irrational, gullible, and deceptive too.
It is in big part due to always clinging to what the leaders of their beloved tribe are saying. Because above all, THEY MUST BE LOYAL TO ISLAM. Their tribe, in which they were born, which means more to them than their own life, it seems.
This makes them, however irrational, deceptive they can be, very strong in unity. By contrast, the individual, independent, highly rational, predominantly honest Westerners are thoroughly divided in persons or small groups.
I see people here wondering how would the merciful God torture a baby if this is a miracle. I really can’t imagine how pitiful it is when a human compares himself with the God. Please grow up little thinkers, are you coming here to interrogate how God should be like or should do!! Who are you to do that ?? Have you forgotten that you were created from a drop of dirty sperm ??!!
Yes we do know that God is the most gracious, the merciful, but God is the most knowledgeable in existence to show his miracle the way he orders based on that knowledge, you can never know the real wisdom behind his acts whoever you are or how much knowledge you think you obtain in your short life. Stop your materialism thinking. You really only show your limitless stupidity when you argue an act of God. Only God knows his wisdom behind any of his acts. And how do you even know that the baby was tortured, is it because you saw him crying. Again you referred to human reasoning, you are not inside the baby to feel what is happening or feeling even if he is crying. God takes care of him in his way. Again it is a God act that you cannot argue or explain.
I am Muslim and in conclusion i would say when the true believers in God see this miracle or other miracles, they don’t boost or raise the level of their believe in God any more, but these miracles are intended only for other non-believers to introduce them to God, and most probable they will come with endless justifications as they did here as we see when they referred this miracle as a disease precisely as their ancestors did in the past to deny such miracles and facts about God because they really do know what this means and what it makes if they don’t influence people around them to deny it. They get jealous because they live with a false religion that made of nothing but claims and has nothing to offer or prove to them about the real God and purpose of life.
Even if they see angels coming down from the sky, they will come up with excuses and justifications to make people around them blindly deny and never believe. This miracle will not make many people believe or return to their mind, but it is just to remind them in the judgment day that God has proved to them one day that he exists so they have no excuse that time, they will only then curse themselves because of the stubborn, blocked mentality they were living with in their past lives.
I am not asking anyone to believe what I am saying, but if you are really concerned to know the ultimate reality and to wake you up from your coma in life , I ask you not to believe me or any Muslim here or there but only to read Quran and Sunnah yourself and you make your judgement after that, but I know many non-believers they will never do this only because they live in their stubborn mentality and they decided to live blind in this live until they wake up after they die where they will no longer have any choice to return to the right path but only remember it was your choice and no one forced you to live with.
It’s funny how all you people try to demean Islam. You all know that Islam is the strongest religion, i mean, look at how many people convert to Islam every year, regardless of the fact that they know people will be racist. They know, by reading the Quran, that it is the true religion. And, like someone else, stated before, I’m also sure 99% of you people have not even read a Quran, so how in the world could you judge it, if you have not read the book that is the backbone and the heart of Islam?
Boring stuff, your words are nothing new. Why do your kinds always say the same thing over and over again.
“It’s funny how all you people try to demean Islam. ”
IT’s not funny. It’s serious. If you considered it as funny than you are the funny one.
“You all know that Islam is the strongest religion, i mean, look at how many people convert to Islam every year”
Statistic please. You forget to mention: the apostates, the hypocrites, the westernized, and the sects. Stongest religion? on what basis? numbers? So, quantity is your best effort? Like a rat? Who are in control of the world now? Which countries are in their way to reach superior status?
“They know, by reading the Quran, that it is the true religion.”
Many people here have read it. Not so great after all, eh? Where is the truth? Talking without proving, eh?
“I’m also sure 99% of you people have not even read a Quran, so how in the world could you judge it, if you have not read the book that is the backbone and the heart of Islam?”
99 %? Where did you get that? your feeling? your fantasy? Have you read this site? It’s obvious that you haven’t. Quran is avaliable in english and muslim here are often quote it, so your statement is just an assumption.
A few weeks ago I noticed that all my posts are deleted from this site…
Interesting…
and NO COMMENT
Maybe some technical failures. Mine was missing too, but just a few.
Ok let,s assume this is real and all you christians asking all these questions why god put pain on this child and etc…to prove
some thing,
my question to you based on your believe jesus died on the cross………dont you think that,s pain …..
well based on our believe he didn,t so Allah (god) can choose to do what ever…..can choose to take ur life any minute
he,s almighty , rules the universe , created life and death , do not argue or doubt him cause one day ur life will end
Your answer is not an asnwer, it’s called an escape because you don’t know how to answer. I doubted this miracle because of many logical reasons not on feeling or vague answers. Can do whatever eh? even lied about heaven and hell? remember, you can’t doubt it or complain about it.
[...] Russian Miracle Baby or Skin Disease? | Faithfreedom.org [...]
[...] Russian Miracle Baby or Skin Disease? | Faithfreedom.org [...]
[...] Russian Miracle Baby or Skin Disease? | Faithfreedom.org [...]
[...] Russian Miracle Baby or Skin Disease? | Faithfreedom.org [...]